This is the blog I didn’t think I’d get to write. But it looks like the planets have aligned to give me one more crack at a tradition unlike any other: the annual “Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning Isn’t a Rivalry” post. Let’s call it “Brady Dominates Manning XVII” because that’s got a nice flow to it.

Sure, their careers have been strangely intertwined. They’re similar ages. Came into the league a short time apart. Each lost one full season to injury. And they’ve met head-to-head with a statistically bizarre frequency. By comparison, Dan Marino and John Elway only faced each other three times in their careers.

But playing against each other a lot does not make you rivals. At least not by the Dictionary.com definition: “a person or thing that is in a position to dispute another’s preeminence or superiority.” Because between the two, there is only one measurement by which you can argue Manning has disputed Brady’s preeminence or superiority. And that is regular-season passing totals. He’s got far more touchdowns and gobs and gobs more passing yards. I could argue that much of that is due to the fact that Manning has never not been surrounded by gifted and freakishly athletic offensive talent, but I won’t. Instead I’ll just concede his advantage in this one category. And add that, even with that, their regular-season passer ratings are well within the polling margin for error, 96.5 for Manning to 96.4 for Brady.

But by no other measurement is it even close. And the more the games have counted over their careers, the bigger Brady’s advantage. Consider:

  • In head-to-head meetings, Brady is 11-5. Meaning that if the two formed their own division, the Bradys would have a bye week in the playoffs and the Mannings would be sitting on a top five pick in the draft.
  • In those 16 matchups, Manning has completed 410-of-657 passes (62.4 percent) for 4,809 yards and 33 TDs with 22 INTs (87.4 QB rating). Brady has completed 367-of-553 passes (66.4 percent) for 4,013 yards and 31 TDs with 13 INTs (96.5 QB rating).
  • Brady has the all-time record for postseason wins by a quarterback with 22. And counting. Manning holds the record for postseason losses by a quarterback with 13. And counting.
  • Manning has four more total career victories than Brady. And 33 more losses.
  • Manning has a record nine one-and-dones in the playoffs. Six of those came after a bye week.
  • According to WEEI’s Mike Mutnansky, 10 of Manning’s postseason losses have come when his team was favored. Brady only has eight postseason losses, period.
  • Brady has thrown two more postseason interceptions than Manning. And 17 more touchdowns.
  • They are tied for Super Bowl interceptions, with four apiece. Manning has three Super Bowl touchdowns. Brady has a record 13.
  • In the only Super Bowl Manning won, his passer rating was 81.8. Brady’s lowest in his six Super Bowls was 82.5.
  • They played in back-to-back Super Bowls, facing the same Seahawks defense. Two years ago Manning put up eight points with a passer rating of 73.5. Last year Brady put up 28, with 14 in the fourth quarter alone, and a rating of 101.1.
  • Simply put, Brady is the best winner ever to play the position. Consider that there are only five quarterbacks all time with as many as 135 wins, regular season and postseason. Brady has 135 more wins than losses.

So we can have our fun and compare and contrast the two because that’s just sports fans doing sports fan things. We just can’t call this a “rivalry” because that ship sailed a long time ago, across a vast ocean of total dominance by Brady. It’s no more a rivalry than the Harlem Globetrotters have a rivalry with the Washington Generals. Or, to steal a phrase from Loki, an ant has no quarrel with a boot.

@JerryThornton1

DraftKings DraftKings has your shot to play for FREE in the $1 Million Fantasy Football Contest THIS SUNDAY! First place takes home $100,000! FOR FREE ENTRY, CLICK HERE.

Blog Author: 
Jerry Thornton
Minihane is wrong again.

[0:00:27] ... like no one else but Andy was also the day when you Tom Brady has left them in the dust to break we'll talk about second but the one thing operatives when you grow up playing ...
[0:01:15] ... go you gotta go way before the pictures from mr. bull before Tom Brady took over you don't go for your practical way way way back five years. Back to when the patriots played miserable before Tom Brady looks at how much they would on a much and AM by and and date they were in the last two years before it. You know they lost the Jack with Scott Zoellick quarterback filling in how many playoff victories the example that. Home. Compared number and play operatives who missed the past couple of dispensed in the question on a lot of protesters are great but. But what if you are operational ticket or Tom Brady Larry Bird. Compared to because maybe the patriots moves. With. So the movement. Just said that I said coming years for Britney ...
[0:02:36] ... Overcame a lot more of a camera and shot. Team to a Super Bowl is it's the greatest and most horrible horrible time all team. Check was the coach we all the desperate coach ever so ...
[0:04:07] ... stop addressing him. This based. Sammy the most transform racial thing that Tom Brady's on the most amazing thing and I guess she from the ten conference championship now he's made his tenth. But he's won ...






Doug Pederson tried to defend his clock management,

[0:02:22] ... a mistake they made. He used to play was a quarterback for Andy Reid Philly. That's one check mark against them like to play yes former players on this good coaches is guys who didn't Harbaugh ...
[0:02:54] ... chick mark in his favorite wasn't stellar no stars we all saw Andy Reid. Bumble butcher at the clock Pakistan forever but Peterson critical plays. It was great baffling to want to pick a Saturday were ...
[0:04:47] ... took us time because number one number one. Did not wanna give Tom Brady ball back we knew we were gonna scores it's not right we knew we had timeouts. And out by Jeffrey alert could elicit your nice guy a chain like you and your ass is. By here I've changed my mind they were down two touchdowns to how much time left in the game when they got the ball that was six. Are gonna get eggs X 66. When. She's six when he now now. Let's give Doug Peterson benefitted out and say he's not panic and oppressed companies actually telling the truth. So we sat there and Alex Smith face to face for the drive towards it out and we're down two touchdowns. We don't want to get your operate all sorts take our time. He cut that lead on the seventh because my I am as we can on the Philadelphia guys they're good they're asking tough questions because when I raise my hands coach coach coach Petersen. Do you understand that when you're down two touchdowns. You have to give Tom Brady the ball back right it's how the rules work you score you kick off. Tom Brady gets the ball back and your only chance of stopping tawdry that's scary that is best if if high school coach said ...
[0:06:25] ... maybe fills in the blacks as I'm about. Did not wanna give Tom Brady ball that we knew we were gonna score. We knew we had timeouts and time. We were also limited. With a number of receivers we had in Jerry Mac comes out of the game time we were down numbers we just didn't wanna feel we did we felt like at that pot at that point. Not to give the ball that Tom Brady we still let timeouts and time even with the onside kick to put ourselves in positions football. Beckett is essentially saying he's ...






Why do people hate Peyton Manning?

[0:04:30] ... dominate scored three point. I swear to god if you go back Peyton Manning has a post game interview the following trying. He says Ali you know I'll sent to I didn't really mean are back there are preparing for that any right well I got a ball anymore. He scored three point the amount of time due to the blog that Ty law and the amount targeted to the bottom Margaret Barrett sent it doesn't strike at the winner you charge you know let. From ...
[0:05:48] ... Blame his line says we had protection isn't single mom who protection Mike Vanderjagt. Who have been projects started. Didn't. The group came in here this is certainly had some problems have been protection. That but ...
[0:08:09] ... I mean Seattle quarterbacks like this. A guy who's everybody's favorite quarterback Cam Newton can win the MVP when all the what are people's choice award these. That was nominated for an Oscar yet everyone. And and they don't like effectively corpus time. And automatically gets race like that that's out 6177797937. The search continues can somebody. Make the case for Peyton Manning and for the Broncos will find out. There any other revenue questions as I can answer you cannot. Yet I haven't asked ...
[0:12:05] ... number we asked the question the question why the F 888 widely Peyton Manning and I've not got a great answer yet oaxley Peyton Manning and Jerry Horton does these people a man. Number two can somebody please tell me why the rockers are gonna win this ...






Welcome to Wednesday’s Morning Mashup. For the latest news, start at our WEEI.com home page or click here for the top stories from our news wire.

Welcome to Wednesday’s Morning Mashup. For the latest news, start at our WEEI.com home page or click here for the top stories from our news wire.

WEDNESDAY’S BROADCAST HIGHLIGHTS:
NBA: Celtics at Raptors, 7:30 p.m. (CSNNE)
NBA: Warriors at Bulls, 8 p.m. (ESPN)
NBA: Hawks at Trail Blazers, 10:30 p.m. (ESPN)
College basketball: Miami at Boston College, 9 p.m. (NBCSN)
College basketball: UCF at South Florida, 6:15 p.m. (ESPNews)
College basketball: Virginia Tech at Notre Dame, 7 p.m. (NESN)
College basketball: Wake Forest at North Carolina, 7 p.m. (ESPN2)
College basketball: Texas at West Virginia, 7 p.m. (ESPNU)
College basketball: Temple at La Salle, 7 p.m. (CBSSN)
College basketball: DePaul at Marquette, 8 p.m. (FS1)
College basketball: Kansas State at Baylor, 8:15 p.m. (ESPNews)
College basketball: Florida State at Louisville, 9 p.m. (ESPNU)
College basketball: Villanova at Seton Hall, 9 p.m. (CBSSN)
College basketball: UCLA at Oregon State, 11 p.m. (ESPNU)
NHL: Blues at Red Wings, 8 p.m. (NBCSN)
NHL: Wild at Ducks, 10:30 p.m. (NBCSN)
Soccer: FA Cup, Tottenham at Leicester, 3 p.m. (FS1)
Tennis: Australian Open, 9 p.m. (ESPN2)

AROUND THE WEB:

Ben Roethlisberger is at a loss to explain why some Broncos players don’t believe he was playing through a shoulder injury in Sunday’s playoff game.

During his weekly appearance on 93.7 The Fan Pittsburgh, Roethlisberger said he was given a painkilling shot to allow him to play Sunday, the first time in his career he’s done that.

“Unbelievable, right? Makes no sense, but it is what it is,” Roethlisberger said of the doubters.

Roethlisberger threw for 339 yards in Pittsburgh’s 23-16 loss, after which some Broncos called the injury into question. Said linebacker Von Miller: “I read through the bluff.”

Roethlisberger said last week that he had a sprained AC joint and torn ligaments in his right shoulder, suffered during the postseason win over the Bengals. Now he’ll have the chance to heal up.

“From what I’ve been told, it won’t need surgery,” Roethlisberger said. “The ligaments will scar up and heal on their own. The only thing he could foresee … down the road some time going in and kind of cleaning out the arthritis and where the scarring is. I don’t foresee any surgeries on the shoulder anytime soon.”

— Pete Rose is headed to the Hall of Fame, but it’s not the one he really wants. The Reds announced Tuesday that they will retire Rose’s No. 14 and induct him into the team’s Hall of Fame.

“This is an honor, that you can’t just believe how you feel,” Rose said at a press conference, adding: “I haven’t given up on Cooperstown. I’m not the type who’s going to give up on anything. But this is fine, I’m happy. … I’m not going to sit here and say it’s the second-best thing, ’cause it’s not. … I’m from Cincinnati. This is the first big thing.”

The team said MLB commissioner Rob Manfred approved the plans to honor Rose, who last month again was denied reinstatement to baseball. The 74-year-old will be feted during ceremonies on June 24-26. The Reds’ 1976 World Series champions also will be recognized as they hold a 40-year reunion.

“Pete was told that in the immediate future, he probably is not going to be able to look in terms of Cooperstown,” Reds chief executive Bob Castellini said. “And we certainly wanted to make sure that we picked up that vacuum. The commissioner gave us permission to do that; we couldn’t be more pleased that it is now. Now’s the time.”

— Two Indianapolis high school girls basketball teams’ seasons were canceled after they got into a bench-clearing brawl, the video of which has made its way around the web.

Ben Davis High School and Pike High School were in the fourth quarter of a chippy game when one player objected to a hard foul and the teams starting fighting.

Indiana High School Athletic Association commissioner Bobby Cox said the teams will not play any more games this season, and the players and coaches will be required to take courses on sportsmanship. Saturday’s game was ruled a double forfeit. It’s up to school administrators to discipline individual players.

“I know that everybody’s seen the videos of these events,” Cox said. “There’s going to be a day when somebody’s going to be catastrophically injured.” The teams will be on probation next season.

ON THIS DAY TRIVIA (answer below): On Jan. 20, 1996, in the NHL All-Star Game at what was then called the FleetCenter in Boston, which Bruin scored with 38 seconds remaining in regulation to give the East a 5-4 victory over the West?

QUOTE OF THE DAY: “With Brady, he’s a great competitor. You know it’s coming. He’s going to cry about getting hit, but he’s going to take the hit and keep going.” Broncos defensive lineman Antonio Smith, on Patriots quarterback Tom Brady

STAT OF THE DAY: 5-16-1 — The Canadiens’ record since the start of December, the league’s worst over that span, following Tuesday’s 4-1 loss to the Bruins

‘NET RESULTS (mobile users, check the website to see the videos): The case against fighting in hockey will get a boost from this AHL battle, as former NHL player Brian McGrattan gets knocked out by Daniel Maggio and lands face first on the ice.

Flyers defenseman Evgeny Medvedev skates out from behind the net and makes a stick save on Maple Leafs forward P.A. Parenteau.

Fresno State guard Cezar Guerrero snares a teammate’s air ball then races over and fires up a buzzer-beating 3-pointer off one leg to send Tuesday’s game against San Diego State into overtime.

TRIVIA ANSWER: Ray Bourque

SOOTHING SOUNDS: Slim Whitman was born on this day in 1924.

Blog Author: 
Jerry Spar
The top stories of the day as recounted by Kirk Minihane.

[0:01:57] ... of that. But I can't these taxes Lexington so ridiculously handsome or private school that would drive me nuts a move that out. That's is part of life for a it was a mystery kid who ...
[0:02:51] ... my Gail Serra pale. What yes I have personal aboard about to Sarah Palin was heavenly. In a minute rotation. From like 2008. Hillary does is get all tied up if you grandmother which she was ...
[0:06:31] ... news CNN poll in New Hampshire. Democratic poll as Bernie Sanders beating Hillary Clinton's winning by thirteen read. Points 6336. You know like point seven Chiat he has secured 33 writes in his sixties she is ...
[0:08:01] ... Either so I guess that's not them and protect horrible. Then now Mike Huckabee and place right but he's. Spree since proposing is that what do they. Nineteen trillion in new spending right now also happens ...






The mouths are running in Denver, must be that thin air. Shots at Gronk and Brady have been fired, we discuss them and how the Patriots might choose to use them for motivation (or not).

[0:00:00] ... Your teammate Antonio Smith says that Tom Brady. We'll take a hit but he also cries about it afterward what kind of things have you heard ...
[0:01:28] ... talked to lift out of I don't know I don't know meet Antonio Smith. Jackson there's another guy there's another guy who was Brandon Marshall brand in my the other grand. I he brought all bets ...
[0:03:31] ... and by the way it's only Tuesday. All they admit they have Chris Harris tell sports honor he was asked today Chris Harris defensive back the Denver Broncos. How do you tackle Brock quote. You've got to hit a low man get him in his ...
[0:07:57] ... Chad Johnson was a patriots player until he wasn't and so was Brandon Lloyd. In Chile was and and and Albert Haynesworth and Corey Dylan and Rodney Harrison and there are a lot of guys before ...






The mouths are running in Denver, must be that thin air. Shots at Gronk and Brady have been fired, we discuss them and how the Patriots might choose to use them for motivation (or not).

[0:00:00] ... Your teammate Antonio Smith says that Tom Brady. We'll take a hit but he also cries about it afterward what kind of things have you heard ...
[0:01:28] ... talked to lift out of I don't know I don't know meet Antonio Smith. Jackson there's another guy there's another guy who was Brandon Marshall brand in my the other grand. I he brought all bets ...
[0:03:31] ... and by the way it's only Tuesday. All they admit they have Chris Harris tell sports honor he was asked today Chris Harris defensive back the Denver Broncos. How do you tackle Brock quote. You've got to hit a low man get him in his ...
[0:07:57] ... Chad Johnson was a patriots player until he wasn't and so was Brandon Lloyd. In Chile was and and and Albert Haynesworth and Corey Dylan and Rodney Harrison and there are a lot of guys before ...






Dale, Michael and Jerry get into a passionate discussion about what Peyton Manning can and cannot do at this age, and how it will play out on Sunday

[0:03:42] ... patriots don't I don't know about having a simple question how is Peyton Manning playing right now does it matter. Think my idol out it doesn't matter I matter it's not it might well let me ...
[0:04:21] ... point completely. A guy who sticks. A guy who has been bad Peyton Manning has been bad I agree with the U nine touchdowns seventy picked. That's not good arms strength not good it should work ...
[0:04:56] ... not good in the post season. If you wanna try to 2004 Peyton Manning fine I will take one of those performances because he he had. Tremendously bad games Manning wanted to mix against the patriots. ...
[0:05:39] ... Tom Brady's debts. His overall post season stats and you look at Peyton Manning's overall post season stats. 58 dramatic difference Peyton Manning has been good in the post season. His teams have been. Under 500 he has the record for postseason losses. Brady has ...