Former Mets general manager and current SiriusXM sports radio host Steve Phillips joined Mut & Merloni (with Kirk Minihane in for Lou Merloni) on Friday to talk about Bobby Valentine, the World Series and performance-enhancing drugs.
Valentine broke his silence following his firing when he appeared on Bob Costas' NBC Sports Network show on Tuesday night, and he made some negative comments about his time in Boston.
“I’m not surprised,” Phillips said. “Having been fired, you get defensive. When Bobby was fired in New York, he had cultivated relationships with members of the media who were able to do his bidding. … He didn’t have the time or the relationships to develop that sort of collateral with the media in Boston, so he’s doing some of that on his own. It’s a natural tendency to defend yourself when you feel like you’ve been wronged.”
Valentine, in the interview, cast doubt on a story he had told WEEI concerning a sarcastic comment to rookie Will Middlebrooks. Phillips said he thinks Valentine could be making things up based on his own perception.
“The answer to that is probably, yes,” Phillips said. “I can’t recall a specific item [in which Valentine made things up]. What happens is, we make up our own reality. What we understand took place may not necessarily be what actually did take place. … I think with Bobby, he does experience things differently. Certainly did to me. I think he does that more than most other people. And I think some of what you’re hearing right now is exactly his reality, which is different than others.”
Asked if Valentine got a fair shake in Boston, Phillips said: “What’s fair? I think that the [Kevin] Youkilis situation blew up on Bobby. It was difficult for him after that to overcome. … They wanted him to be a changer … and in doing that it was going to rub some people the wrong way.”
Phillips said if he were a general manager again he would consider hiring Valentine, just not immediately.
“I would consider Bobby to manage again, probably not this year.” Phillips said. “I think the dust needs to settle. … I think that as time goes by we start to better understand who is responsible for what and stuff that we attach to somebody that might not have been their stuff. The facts become little bit clearer, so I think somewhere down the line I would consider Bobby to manage. I think he’s a brilliant baseball man. I think it has to be the right situation.”
Following are more highlights from the interview.
On new Sox manager John Farrell: “I’ve crossed paths with him both from a front office perspective and when he was Red Sox pitching coach. … I know he is very well-respected, a very mature baseball guy. I followed some games up in Toronto with him when they were decimated by injuries, so the one thing I’ll say is that with all the injuries the Red Sox had, you’ve got a manager coming in who at least have knows how to handle some of that situation because he dealt with that himself this past year. … Where he’ll have an impact is that he’s not Bobby Valentine. And I say that with respect to Bobby, but he’s more like Terry Francona and he will be much more readily accepted and won’t have to start from scratch earning the respect of the players, of the fans, of the front office, and of everybody else.”
On the Giants taking a 2-0 lead over the Tigers in the World Series: “I had Tigers in 6. So, I think the Tigers have got them right where they want them right now. Hasn’t gone quite how I thought it would’ve. [Justin] Verlander would’ve won Game 1 and maybe even split the series in San Francisco. That being said, I do think that the Tigers are not out of this series. So many people are discounting them right now. They’re going back to Detroit with a fan base that is really behind their team; they play really well there. … I think they can bounce back in this series, it’s not going to be easy. This is a Giants team that is playing inspired baseball, to say the least. Overcoming six elimination games is nothing to laugh at. … I believe the Tigers will find a way to bounce back.”
On the Giants not being punished as a team for having a player, Melky Cabrera, test positive for PEDs: “There’s nothing that’s taken into account with the fact that the team that you’re playing on gets a dramatic benefit in your performance from the fact that you were cheating. ... He was the centerpiece of their offense. So from my perspective to say let’s dock him 50 games but not in any way acknowledge the fact that the San Francisco Giants benefited from his performance, I don’t know what that exact number is. I personally believe that it could be anywhere from eight to 10 games, that if they had some other guy there or if it was the Melky Cabrera who was a Yankee and Brave who was like a .265 hitter with eight home runs on the season, knocked in 48 and scored 50, if that were the guy then they would be eight to 10 games less than what they were. But he was their best offensive player.”
The playmaker, Hall of Famer Michael Irvin checks in and helps us set the stage for Broncos and Patriots this Sunday in Foxboro.
Kyle Arrington, filing in for Devin MCcourty, previews Pats-Broncos
Adam Schefter, ESPN Insider, joins the guys to talk Pats-Broncos, Brady-Manning and the rest of the NFL.
Its time to start the season for the Celtics! We talk about the things we like about the Celtics and the things we dont like very much. Plus Sam feels like a jerk for laughing at Julius Randle.
Jackie MacMullan joins MFB for the first time this season. She discusses the rejection of NBA lottery reform, Rajon Rondo, and the Celtics chances this season.
Mut, Rob Bradford and Alex Speier are back and talking not only Red Sox, but MLB Hot Stove. They talk with Red Sox GM Ben Cherington, and take some phone calls about some of the Red Sox potential moves.
Mut, Rob Bradford, and Alex Speier talk with Red Sox GM Ben Cherington. Ben addresses some questions regarding Will Middlebrooks, Rusney Castillo, as well as Yoenis Cespedes' future with the club.
Joe Castiglione does his annual wrap-up of the season by reading the poem by Bart Giamatti.
We discuss the Bruins blown 2 goal lead against the Wild at the Garden and where they go from here with the great Jack Edwards of NESN.
NESN's Andy Brickley joined the show following Boston's 4-3 loss to the Minnesota Wild. Brick talked about Patrice Bergeron's line getting beat a lot, the Bruins' lack of focus in their 6 losses, and the big blow to the defense with Torey Krug's injury.
Joe McDonald joins the guys to talk to about the Chara injury and how the Bruins will move forward without him.
Happy birthday Kirk!!!!
The top stories of the day as recounted by Kirk Minihane.
The guys got dressed up for Kirk's 40th.
MFB and the callers wish a very Happy 40th Birthday to Kirk Minihane
Three For All, Ebola Scare
Dale, Steve DeOssie and Tom E Curran of CSNNE put the final touches on a week of discussion about the upcoming showdown in Foxboro vs. the Denver Broncos on Sunday.
We send out well wishes to our friend and colleague Bob 'Neumy' Neumier
Mikey, Villani and Lenny are talking about the 2004 Red Sox on the anniversary of Game 4 of the ALCS with Dave Roberts steal abd Bill Mueller driving him in and what it was like to witness.
Mikey, Mut and Lenny are talking about the Patriots and how they have stacked up through the years and what got them to the three championships and five Super Bowl appearances in the Brady-Belichick era.
Mikey and Mut take a call from someone who wants to criticize Belichick the GM and his history of drafting players and making moves in the draft.
The playoffs are here and we are ready! Brad Feldman joins the show to talk about the Revs vs the Crew. We also talk about the newest addition to the MLS.
WEEI.com’s Scott McLaughlin is joined by Joe Meloni of College Hockey News on the first episode of the College Puckcast. They talk about the wrist injury that will sideline Boston College defenseman Steve Santini until at least January, as well as the good start for Boston University and its star freshman, Jack Eichel. Other topics include fast starts for Vermont and UMass-Lowell and slow starts for Providence and Northeastern.
The top stories of the day as recounted by Kirk Minihane.More from this show