ESPN's Tim Kurkjian joined Mut & Merloni Wednesday to offer his thoughts about Red Sox spring training. New manager Bobby Valentine has come in and made some changes in the team's approach to the preseason, and Kurkjian said that some of those changes haven't been as well-received by all the players.
"I think he's doing the right thing. I think it's something that he has to do," Kurkjian said. "Overall, it's going just OK, from what I can see. My warning -- if that's the right term -- to all the Red Sox players is, Bobby Valentine is first and foremost a teacher. He is not going to allow somebody to say something or, more important, do something incorrectly and then get away with it. Bobby is going to correct them no matter who they are, and it's going to be done his way.
"When I say that, trust me when I tell you this: His way is the right way. He's going to teach them the way to get a secondary lead, how to do cutoffs and relays, and if they don't listen to him, he's going to keep harping on it. And the teaching is not going to end in spring training. It is going to go through the rest of the season. All Red Sox fans and players should understand that this is going to continue, and yet they will never -- never -- be outfoxed in a game as long as Bobby Valentine is managing."
Asked to further explain his comment that "it's going just OK," Kurkjian said: "That's what I sense, is that the players didn't know what to make of Bobby yet. And Bobby didn't know what to make of the Red Sox system yet. Now, this is probably all normal and natural for a guy who's coming in making some changes, hasn't managed in the major leagues in 10 years. All of this is expected.
"And yet, I think it's been even more confusing for some of the players, like, 'Why are we doing this?' I'm telling you, though, eventually, whether it's late in spring training or that game in early May, they're going to look back and say, 'That's why we did that in spring training. We just got an out on a play because we were prepared for it.' Bobby will have them prepared for everything. And again, if they don't like it, I don't think he cares about that. He's going to get it right, no matter what. Even is some of the players are wondering, 'What are we doing here?' "
Outfielder Carl Crawford is looking to bounce back from a disappointing 2011 season, his first in Boston after signing as a free agent. Kurkjian said he does not have high expectations.
"I'm hopelessly positive about things, but I don't think he's in the right place right now -- not meaning Boston. I mean, I think at this point he's going to have a similar year to last year, as opposed to those really good years in Tampa Bay," Kurkjian said. "As we know, this guy's all about comfort, he's all about trust. At least that's what the Rays people have told me. And if he's not comfortable and he doesn't trust the people around him -- meaning all the people around him -- he's not going to be the player that he needs to be.
"I didn't sense from spring training that he was in the right place mentally. He is going to have to be if he's going to be a different player than last year. You guys saw it: He was tentative in the outfield. He was tentative on the bases. Nobody that fast should be stealing [only] 18 bases in a season. And he didn't swing the bat like he did in Tampa Bay, either. He is crucial to this team being a really good team. One through six in this order should be the best in the American League, but only if he's the 2 hitter and the Carl Crawford from Tampa Bay. And I'm not sure he's that guy right now."
Following are more highlights from the conversation.
On the difference in Valentine's managerial style from his rookie season to now: "He's just smarter certainly than he was back then. He was young, he was impulsive, and even though he still believes he's the smartest guy in the room, now he has a more diplomatic way of going about explaining that. So, even though he'll yell at a player now and show some frustration, he has grown up to the point to understand that the players have changed dramatically from 1985 to 2012, and that dealing with the players is now -- he has to be more than just a teacher, he has to be a master psychologist to figure out, 'How am I going to get the best out of these guys?' That's what I think he's learned. And this thought that he's going to come in and just push everybody around, that simply is not going to happen. He's going to push, but when he realizes, 'If I push this guy too hard he's not going to respond,' that's what Bobby has learned in the last 27 years."
On shortstop Jose Iglesias: "I don't think he's going to be the starting shortstop. That's certainly not what I gathered with my one day [at spring training] with the Red Sox -- that he's going to Triple-A and he needs to work on what he can do at the plate. With this lineup you would think you could flip him in there, tell him to hit .190 and we're going to be fine. But at the same time, he needs some more seasoning. And that's why Mike Aviles is there. That's why Nick Punto is there."
The guys have even more reaction to Deflategate and if this is actually a showdown between Bill and Roger.
Tom E. Curran calls the boys during his layover in Denver and gets right into the Deflategate craziness. Tom talks about his knowledge of the situation including his thoughts on if the NFL was indeed trying to set up and catch the Pats in the act. He gets into the relationship between Belichick and the league office, Belichick and Kraft and the actual game on Super Bowl Sunday.
Greg and Steve discuss the Deflategate debacle with callers and give their theories as to what went down in Foxboro last week against the Colts. Both guys think that Pats may be guilty of doing something to the balls, but that so do most other teams. Will Belichick and Brady be punished? Not if the NFL doesn't have proof, which it's looking more and more like they don't.
Ben and Sam discuss ways to improve the NBA All-Star weekend, hand out of hardware, and give their Finals predictions
Jackie MacMullen, ESPN Boston, talks with MFB about Rondo being traded to the Dallas Mavericks, and how this will have an effect on the Celtics rebuild process
How have the Celtics looked after a couple weeks? Could they be a playoff team? These questions and more...
The Red Sox have taken over Foxwoods and Red Sox Manager John Farrell sat down with Mut and Bradford to talk about the roster and how the 2015 season is looking.
Red Sox pitcher Joe Kelly and 3B Pablo Sandoval sat down with Mut and Bradford. Joe Kelly had a few interesting proclamations. First he said that 95% of pitchers use some sort of grip enhancer, and then he said he was going to win the Cy Young. Pablo leaned over and promised 10 HR's, explaining to Joe that the trick is to set the bar low.
Mut and Rob are in on the Hot Stove Show this week and they're taking calls and talking about the Red Sox pitching as we are 5 weeks away from pitchers and catchers reporting to spring training.
Pierre McGuire talks about ways hockey players skirt the rules in the NHL and the development of Dougie Hamilton.
Pierre McGuire joins Lou, Christian and Tim to discuss the resurgent Bruins, the emergence of David Pastrnak, and former Boston College stand-out Johnny Gaudreau looking to trademark the name 'Johnny Hockey.'
We get our state of the B report from NESN's Jack Edwards, right in the midst of a 4 game winning streak and hot return for David Pastrnak.
Tim Hasselbeck joined the show to give his expertise on deflate gate.
The top stories of the day as recounted by Kirk Minihane.
The guys opened the show discussing who was lying yesterday.
The guys react to comments made by Former Carolina Panthers General Manager Marty Hurney
After Tom Brady answered questions for a half hour about Deflate-Gate, the guys discuss whether or not they believe him.
Adam Schefter, ESPN, talks everything Deflate Gate with Lou, Christian and Tim on Patriots Friday
We get the national perspective on Deflategate and the Patriots-Seahawks Super Bowl with the playmaker, Hall of Famer Michael Irvin.
We discuss deflategate and move beyond it for some game talk with Tom E Curran of CSNNE
Michael, Jerry and Andy Hart of PFW continue the dialogue and try and find some sanity in this sea of madness.
A caller named Jumbo from California raises a question that hasn't been talked about too much, what happens if it's determined that the Patriots aren't found responsible for the deflation of the footballs?
Mut and Lenny continue talking and taking calls on deflategate, as well as hearing the sound from Kirk Minihane's appearance on the O'Reilly Factor.
Mut and Lenny are talking deflategate and what impact it could have on the Patriots organization.
Chris and comedian Mike Mulloy recap the final Raw before the Rumble and preview the Rumble itself.
Would you rather watch important games in the stadium or on TV? Also we discuss our worst experiences at stadiums.
Ben and Sam discuss ways to improve the NBA All-Star weekend, hand out some hardware, and give their Finals predictions.
Tim Hasselbeck joined the show to give his expertise on deflate gate.More from this show
After his emotional reaction on NFL Live following Tom Brady's press conference yesterday, Mark Brunell joins Lou, Christian and Tim about all things Deflate GateMore from this show
The guys react to comments made by Former Carolina Panthers General Manager Marty HurneyMore from this show