With the Red Sox just a couple of weeks away from playing the Twins 66 times in 20 days, you are just about guaranteed a Sox, Bruins or Celtics game on TV (usually at least two) every night over the next couple of months. So I figured now was as good a time as any to take a look at the fellas who will be broadcasting the games locally and rank them from best to worst.
Two notes before we start:
1) I separated them into two groups, play-by-play and analysts. Comparing a basketball announcer to a hockey guy is apple and oranges enough, but comparing Jerry Remy to, say, Mike Gorman seems even more convoluted.
2) There are radio broadcasts as well, obviously, for the three teams, but the Powers That Be at WEEI won't let me comment on them. Why? Well, the Red Sox and Celtics are on WEEI and the Bruins are on another sports station (probably you've heard of it). Do I have opinions? Sure I do. But this isn't the place, evidently. Feel free to e-mail me at kminihane@weei.com or ask me on Twitter @kirkmin and I'll be happy to answer.
Here we go ...
PLAY-BY-PLAY
1. Mike Gorman (Comcast, though it'll always be SportsChannel to me)
The absolute gold standard, the Walter Cronkite of local play-by-play guys. I've never heard anyone criticize the way Mike Gorman calls a basketball game. He clearly knows the game, follows the league closely, does his homework, has the voice, all that stuff. So do plenty of others, or at least some others. What separates Gorman is that very rare ability to both a) never make himself the story yet b) still rise to the occasion when that great call is needed. Here's two examples, 26 years apart. Watch both (Bird's game-winner comes around the 5:30 mark) and you'll see what I mean. Never lets the moment overwhelm him, doesn't say too much but not too little, either. Listen to how he calls the Carmelo Anthony miss after the Allen 3-pointer and you'll see what I mean. Other announcers would be flustered after the Allen shot, expecting a timeout or still recovering from a ridiculously scripted "HOW LOUD CAN I GET?" call after the make (Gus Johnson is now an SNL skit of Gus Johnson). Gorman takes his time, notes the Knicks are out of timeouts, and allows the play to breathe all the way to the buzzer.
I'm hugely biased, probably, because I grew up with Gorman (and Gil Santos) calling Bird/Parish/McHale ("Thinking about it … wants it … got it!"). But I think I can recognize slippage -- look at Tim McCarver or John Madden or Dick Stockton or Dan Shaughnessy (how'd that get in here?) -- and I just don't see it with Gorman. He's as good now as he was in 1986, 1996 or five years ago. I'm thankful he never went national (and he could have, on his worst day he's three times the play-by-play announcer Stockton, Brent Musburger or Bob Neal ever were, and they all had national spots) and I'm thankful he was always confident enough in his ability to never feel the need to dip a toe into schtickdom.
Look, he's local, been here forever, you and I know he wants the Celtics to win and he knows that you and I know. But it doesn't get in the way, it's simply never an issue. You can root for a team to win without being a homer, and Gorman has always managed to balance that perfectly. And thank God for it, because Tommy would be completely unsalvageable if partnered with anyone with even a whiff of "us against them." We'll get to Heinsohn in a bit, but to sit next to a guy that believes every referee is out to screw the Celtics every night and not let it affect your performance borders on staggering. Part of it is chemistry and comfort, which makes it easier -- Mike and Tommy clearly have great affection for each other, and the occasional portrayal of Edith to Tommy's Archie over the last 30 years has made for good business -- but to keep Tommy on track (most of the time) might be Gorman's signature triumph as a broadcaster.
The WNBA is unwatchable. We all know this, nothing needs to be added. But if I'm flipping around and I hear Gorman calling a Connecticut Sun game (which he's done the last couple of years) I'll stick around for a few minutes. Mike Gorman can make me watch a WNBA game. There is no greater tribute.
2. Don Orsillo (NESN)
This is Don Orsillo's 12th season as the (or at least a) play-by-play guy for the Sox? Really? Does it seem that long to you?
Maybe I'm wrong (usually I am) and maybe it doesn't really matter, but it strikes me that Orsillo has never been embraced by Red Sox Nation. That's not even a knock, but Orsillo just hasn't made that connection, hasn't entered the "one of us" world. To me, he's a perfectly serviceable play-by-play announcer. He talks too much, yup. He can be vanilla on vanilla with a side of vanilla, true. And the Red Sox could be 2-156 on September 28th and the next negative word from Orsillo would be the first that season. But that seems to be the NESN way. If they wanted an opinionated guy in that seat Sean McDonough would still be there (also money was a factor) next to Remy. But instead they took 70 cents on the McDonough dollar and lived with it. Is a Don Orsillo/Jerry Remy broadcast in the class of McDonough/Remy? Not even close, at its peak McDonough and Remy were the best local team -- any sport -- in my lifetime. Orsillo and Remy are just OK, nothing more and nothing less. Part of it is Remy, who has really slipped the last few years (more on that later). But Orsillo allows Remy to be lazy, encourages the giggles and all the Remy self-promotion. It can be funny at times, but I know it wears on me over the course of 162 games. Still, if you have MLB Extra Innings and have been subjected to other local broadcasts you know that it could be a lot worse. Don Orsillo will never approach greatness, will never be Vin Scully or Mel Allen or Ned Martin or Sean McDonough, but he's safe and competent. Not a ringing endorsement until you think about Chip Caray or Hawk Harrelson in your life for eight months.
3. Jack Edwards (NESN)
Nothing's changed. I'm told he's a very nice guy, and I think he's actually terrific on The Big Show, but I can't shake the idea that I'm watching an act. He's John Sterling, plain and simple. Jack Edwards -- not the Bruins -- is the star of the broadcast, and as a viewer it wears me out. And it's not radio, Jack, feel free to grab some air every 15 minutes or so. For me, just unlistenable because it never feels authentic. It's worked for him -- he's become the voice for all Bruins homers, got a new deal out of the run last year -- and it sure appears I'm alone on this island.
ANALYSTS
1. Andy Brickley (NESN)
Supporting characters in "The Artist" have more dialogue in one scene than Brickley might have on an entire six-game road trip, but when Edwards does yield the floor he does so to a network-level analyst. Brickley is smart, self-deprecating (an underrated yet almost vital quality to the job), never afraid to criticize the Bruins, quick to the point (though what other choice does he have?) and always relevant. It's a hell of feat to speak (maybe) 20 percent of the time and still save a broadcast, but Brickley pulls it off.
2. Jerry Remy (NESN)
Can still be funny, can still be insightful and is so past the point of being untouchable that he has free rein to say whatever he wants and often does so. Remy will kill an umpire for missing a call that actually helps the Red Sox, which is extraordinarily rare for a local analyst. But he isn't as sharp, focused or energetic as he was even five years ago. Part of it is obviously health-related, but it often feels like Remy is mailing it in. My best guess is that he can stay as long as he wants -- and he's not going anywhere, if only because all of his business interests are so tied to that job -- but in a perfect world I'd like to see Dennis Eckersley at the very least sharing the booth with Orsillo and Remy (though that would mean more of the dreadful Jim Rice in studio with the superb Tom Caron).
3. Tommy Heinsohn (Comcast)
All the referee stuff used to bother me to the point of muting, but I've come to grips with reality. Tommy is Tommy and it's never going to change. The guy will be 78 years old in August -- he's the same age as Gino Cappelletti, but while Gino sounds frail and confused, Tommy is nothing if not robust -- and what you get is as cemented as it gets. And if you can get past the anti-Celtics paranoia and cartoonish homerism, there is always this about Tommy: He's remains as good as anyone at breaking down the game. I'll go back to that same playoff win over the Knicks we talked about earlier. Tommy knew the play the Celtics were going to run for Allen at the end of the game, was correctly blasting Mike D'Antoni for not getting Amar'e Stoudemire shots down the stretch after Stoudemire dominated the game for the first three quarters, also predicted the inbounds alley-oop to Garnett from Rondo on the possession before the Allen 3-pointer. Just sharp stuff, and that's not infrequent but often gets lost in the buffoonery.
Patriots punter Zoltan Mesko joined D&C to chat about being labeled the most interesting man in the NFL. He shows off his multilingual skills, who he idolizes, and his upcoming charity event.
Christopher Price joins John Ryder to discuss Wes Welker signing his franchise tender. They also discuss what a crowded Patriots receiver corps will look like once the season starts, as well as the situation in the backfield.
Wes Welker joins Mut and Merloni to discuss his current contract status with the Patriots, if he thinks he'll be at the mandatory mini camp in June, and if he can see himself missing regular season games.
Celtics radio analyst Cedric Maxwell joined D&C to chat about the Celtics lack of effort in Game 6. He discusses how Bradley has enhanced Rondo's play, the C's lack of depth dues to injury, and what the Celtics need to do to win Game 7.
Sean talked with the coach about the big Game 5 comeback, and about the team's different configurations.
Paul talks with Sean & Max about Avery Bradley's health, and about the Celtics' history with closeout games.
NESN Red Sox analyst Jerry Remy joined the guys to discuss why the Sox have been playing better since their players only meeting. He touches on how fun its been to watch their makeshift lineup play, Bobby Valentine's shuffling his roster due to injuries, and Adrian Gonzalez willingness to play the outfield to help the team.
Bobby Valentine & Joe Castiglione on a rare no-move day today in Baltimore to preview Sox/irds
Red Sox Manager Bobby Valentine joined D&C to discuss Kevin Youkilis' return from the DL. He also discusses juggling his lineup with all the injuries, Adrian Gonzalez volunteering to play the outfield, team leadership, and how the players only meeting influenced the Sox turnaround.
Bruins Defensman Andrew Ference wraps up the Bruins Game 7 loss. He touches on just how the Capitals beat them, what his thought were on Ovechkin's performance, and how Tim Thomas' decision not to attend the White House visit affected the team.
NESN's Andy Brickley joined Dennis and Callahan to discuss the NHL playoffs and preview game 7 of the Bruins and Captials.
We're joined by NESN's own Jack Edwards after the Bruins knocked off the Caps in dramatic fashion to force a game 7 showdown this Wednesday at the Garden. Jack says: Bet on the Bear!
Celtics radio analyst Cedric Maxwell joined D&C to chat about the Celtics lack of effort in Game 6. He discusses how Bradley has enhanced Rondo's play, the C's lack of depth dues to injury, and what the Celtics need to do to win Game 7.
NESN Red Sox analyst Jerry Remy joined the guys to discuss why the Sox have been playing better since their players only meeting. He touches on how fun its been to watch their makeshift lineup play, Bobby Valentine's shuffling his roster due to injuries, and Adrian Gonzalez willingness to play the outfield to help the team.
D&C discuss Lisa Salters interview/lovefest with Allen Iverson in the middle of the 2nd quater of Game 6. The boys talk about the timing and length of the interview, how broke Iverson is, and the impressive run the Celtics had during the interview.
Buster Olney joins Mut and Lou to discuss the latest on the Youkilis trade front, Bob McClure, what Cole Hamels will get in free agency, and if Hal Steinbrenner is really trying to sell the Yankees.
Mut and Lou try to figure out why Daniel Bard is no longer throwing in the high 90's.
Tim Legler joins Mut and Merloni to talk about the Celtics loss to the Sixers and what he expects will happen in Game 7.
As the news comes down that Gonzalez is playing in the outfield, we debate how smart a move this is, and what, if any, alternatives did the Red Sox have?
Former NBA player/current analyst for TNT Steve Kerr chatted with Glenn and Michael and gave his thoughts on the Celts/Sixers, Heat/Pacers and Thunder/Spurs series'.
Even with the Celtics make a nice run in the Eastern Conference NBA playoffs, watching Oklahoma City and San Antonio play has made it abundantly clear that one of those teams will likely win the whole thing. We discuss.
Kirk wrote a column about David Ortiz that Mikey didn't completely agree with and a debate ensues.
Ryder and Kirk talk about what the Red Sox might do when their injured position players start making their return to the lineup and what that could mean for the struggling Kevin Youkilis.
Ryder and Kirk Minihane are talking about Josh Becketts impressive outing against the Seattle Mariners. They also talk about the Celtics-76ers series and how much energy the Celtics will have in game 3.
MOTWU tickles Michael, Ortiz feels the heat, and the Celts get their props.
The goon croons for a lost BeeGee, and Metallica on the accordion never sounded better.
Rhode Islanders vs Schilling... and they ain't happy.
Celtics head coach Doc Rivers called into D&C this morning to discuss his team's dominating second half performance in Game 5. He touches on how the C's clicked in the second half, the character of his team, why Rondo is so special, and the keys to Brandon Bass' big night.
More from this showFormer NBA player/current analyst for TNT Steve Kerr chatted with Glenn and Michael and gave his thoughts on the Celts/Sixers, Heat/Pacers and Thunder/Spurs series'.
More from this showCeltics TV play-by-play voice Mike Gorman joined John & Gerry to discuss the personality of this Celtics team. He also talks about if the Celtics are taking this season as their last shot at a championship, what was the key moment that turned the season around, and if KG will return to Boston next season.
More from this showMut and Lou discuss David Ortiz's comments after last night's game about not getting enough respect from the front office and media.
More from this showKirk talks with John Mitchell, who wrote Wednesday that Kevin Garnett could face backlash from racist fans in Boston should the Celtics lose the series to the 76ers.
More from this show