I've always considered there to be seven categories of pro sports athletic achievement. In ascending order of accomplishment:
-- All-Star/Pro Bowler
-- First Team All-Star/All-Pro
-- League MVP
-- Team Hall/Wall/Ring of Fame
-- Hall of Famer
-- Number Retired
-- Statue Worthy
But watching this past weekend's Patriots-Jets game on CBS, it occurred to me that there's another, higher, more prestigious level of honor in the sports pantheon. Rarer even than being cast in bronze outside a venue for tourists to pose in front of, birds to perch on and winos to pee against. One I'd never really considered before.
“The Uncriticizable.”
It happens in sports, but it's exceptionally rare. It's the status few athletes obtain. When he's regarded as so elite that he becomes a sacred cow, above any kind of criticims. Infallible. Untouchable.
It's a much higher and rarer honor than just some work of taxpayer-financed art. Hell, Boston is lousy with public works projects in honor of Ted Williams. A statue, a street next to Fenway, a tunnel/future site of a major flooding disaster. And even the Greatest Hitter That Ever Lived wasn't immune to criticism. On the contrary, Ted was slandered, libeled, called words you never heard in the Bible. For 20-plus years, critics came after him from all directions like ninjas and blamed him for everything short of Pearl Harbor.
Look at the chaos surrounding the Red Sox right now. The great unwashed peasants of Boston ... and believe me, I consider myself among the least washed and most peasanty ... are in full revolution. And even among the guys with championship rings in that clubhouse full of beers and buckets of the Colonel, no one is being spared. Like Ben Affleck said in “Good Will Hunting,” “You're all suspect.”
But there are ballplayers who are somehow immune to any criticism. Where for some reason media and fans alike will twist themselves into verbal pretzels to ever say a single negative thing about the guy. And the latest pro player to join the ranks of the Uncriticizable is Jets cornerback Darrelle Revis.
To be clear, I like Revis' game. You'd have to be an idiot not to. He's among the best in the league. Personally, I'd take the Packers' Charles Woodson and the Eagles' Nnamdi Asomugha over him, but it's close, and that's not the point of this rant. The point is that it became painfully obvious watching the Jim Nantz-Phil Simms broadcast of Sunday's game that Revis has evolved beyond mere mortal and become one of the Uncriticizables.
In the first half, they wanted to make the case that Revis is a receiver-smothering force of nature who can't be reasoned with, can't be bargained with, and who won't stop, ever, until your pass is incomplete. So, to make the case they showed three clips: Revis playing solid press coverage on Wes Welker, a Patriots run play he wasn't involved with, and a zone coverage play when Revis covered no one, while we heard how crucial he was in all three. They could've showed a shot of him going to the bench and chugging a pint of Gatorade, and Simms would've explained how Welker wasn't open during the timeout.
But it was on the plays when Revis clearly messed up for the world to see that he got the Papal Infallibility Doctrine treatment. He dragged Deion Branch to the ground beyond five yards from the line of scrimmage and got flagged for illegal contact, which gets called twice a game in today's NFL. But Nantz basically accused Branch of acting out the Mr. Spock death scene from “Wrath of Khan.”
On the first play from scrimmage after the half, Simms lectured us about the amazing job Revis was doing “taking Wes Welker out of the game.” Which came as news to Welker or anyone else who was aware he was sitting on three catches for 47 yards to that point. And no sooner had the words come out of Simms' mouth than Welker was running a skinny post past Revis Island and back out into the open ocean for a 73-yard pickup. But once again, Revis is above criticism of any kind, so the blame was laid off on the safety. A kindness that wouldn't have been afforded to say, the Pats' Devin McCourty or Kyle Arrington or even Revis' own teammate Antonio “Octodad” Cromartie.
To be clear, I'm not ripping Darrelle Revis. Like I said, he's a hell of a cover corner. In today's NFL, defensive backs get burnt more often than smelly Occupy Boston dope fiends. It's the nature of the game. And nothing to be ashamed of. I just refuse to watch the emperor get undressed by another elite football player in Welker and say he's fully clothed.
I don't know, maybe it's a New York thing. Because there's been no more sacred a cow in our lifetimes than Derek Jeter. We've witnessed 16 big years of Captain Intangible's career now, and I feel like the next negative thing I hear about him coming out of New York will be the first. I grant you, he's been a part of a lot of championships, and if that's the standard by which you want to judge him, I'm all for it. But he's one of those guys that even when he's wrong, he's right.
Jeter's skills have been diminishing for years. His defense doesn't pass the eyeball test or the Sabermetrics test and he's by any objective standard one of the weakest shortstops in MLB. He's considered the ultimate “team first” guy, but if he really put the club's best interest ahead of his own he would've let Alex Rodriguez move to short years ago. And he's been coasting on his reputation as a clutch player for even longer.
In Game 5 of the American League Division Series, with the Yankees down 3-2 in the eighth, two outs and the runner going, Jeter swung at the first pitch. The base was all but stolen and would've put the tying run in scoring position. But Jeter swung away and lifted a fly ball to the warning track. Notwithstanding that Yankee Stadium is the easiest sea-level hitter's park in the majors and balls fly out of there like they were Pro-V1s. He hit a lazy fly ball with the season on the line. And all we heard out of New York was that Captain Clutch "almost" hit one out. And all the criticism was aimed at poor, hapless, unloved A-Rod for striking out twice. Because when it comes to taking the blame for failure, Jeter is rubber and A-Rod is glue.
I'd have to say the Patron Saint of the Uncriticizable in our lifetimes is Brett Favre. The all time master of Blame Avoidance. It sounds impossible, but Brett Favre's (Reminder: It's always “Brett Favre,” 100 percent of the time. Calling him just “Favre” would be like calling Superman “Man”) rumpswabs in the media managed to find more cliches to explain away his bad decisions than Fav- than BrettFavre made bad decisions. “He was trying to make a play.” “He's so capable of throwing the ball into tight windows, it was open to him.” “He's a Mississippi riverboat gambler.” “He's an old gunslinger.” “He was just having fun out there, sending that Jets massage therapist pictures of his junk.” OK, I might have made up that last one. But life when BrettFavre was playing was what North Korea must feel like. Where Dear Leader can do no wrong, no matter how many gawdawful picks he throws.
To be fair, there are guys who win so much and play at such a high level for so long, they've earned Uncriticizable status. Wayne Gretzky. Michael Jordan. Joe Montana. Albert Pujols. My beef isn't with them at all. It's with the ones who get a reputation for perfection and can't shake it despite all evidence to the contrary.
I suppose the reason I get so frustrated by the existence of these Uncriticizable Ones is that I'm from Boston. And I honestly feel like we don't have those here. That doesn't fly with us. We simply don't play the sacred cow worship game thing here. Believe me, I'm a fanboy, and as shameless a suckup as anyone I know. But even I don't give anyone the "do no wrong" treatment like the guys I've mentioned get.
The closest we come in Boston to a guy who's above criticism is Tom Brady. And even he doesn't get a free pass. Believe me, I wish he did. All this guy has done is be for my money the best Boston athlete of my lifetime. Playing by far the toughest position in sports at a level few have ever played it. Twice the MVP. Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year. Two of the top five QB passer ratings in NFL history. Every day I practice the pose I'll use next to his statue so I can make it my Facebook profile picture. But when he had a bad game against Buffalo a few weeks ago, no one was saying he didn't or blaming the refs or saying he didn't throw four picks. Not even Tom Brady, who's his own worst critic.
Not long ago I saw a cousin from out of state who's a casual football fan that I hadn't seen in months. And as is the case with 90 percent of my conversations, we talked about the Patriots. And a minute in the guy asked why Brady threw that interception. “Wait. Which one?” He was referring to the one on the first drive. In the playoff game. Back in January. “Yeah, that one. What happened with that? That was awful.” The one that broke a record streak of 358 consecutive passes without a pick. Unlike other cities, even our most sacred cow can end up on a burger roll.
Next to Brady, the most dominant Boston ballplayer I've ever seen was Pedro Martinez. And he wasn't immune from criticism. All things considered, Tim Thomas had the greatest single season any athlete in this town has ever had. And it wasn't until the Cup was won that he got the credit he deserved. Paul Pierce is the shooting guard on the Celtics' all-time starting five, but he's taken his lumps in the past. You have to look long and hard to find a guy in this town that didn't take crap from somebody.
The closest I can come to as examples of guys who could even be considered above reproach:
-- Over a long career: Bobby Orr, Larry Bird, Kevin McHale, Ray Bourque, Curtis Martin, Cam Neely and Tedy Bruschi
-- In a shorter sample: Vince Wilfork, Dustin Pedroia
And that's about all I can come up with. Everyone else that's come through here has been regarded as suspect in some way or another. On the field or off. It's not much of a list considering the number of truly great athletes we've seen come through this town. I guess it's just not in our nature to see an athlete and pretend he can do no wrong the way other cities do. We might build a statue of a guy, it doesn't necessarily mean we'll put him on a pedestal.
Follow Jerry on Twitter @JerryThornton1
Patriots punter Zoltan Mesko joined D&C to chat about being labeled the most interesting man in the NFL. He shows off his multilingual skills, who he idolizes, and his upcoming charity event.
Christopher Price joins John Ryder to discuss Wes Welker signing his franchise tender. They also discuss what a crowded Patriots receiver corps will look like once the season starts, as well as the situation in the backfield.
Wes Welker joins Mut and Merloni to discuss his current contract status with the Patriots, if he thinks he'll be at the mandatory mini camp in June, and if he can see himself missing regular season games.
Celtics radio analyst Cedric Maxwell joined D&C to chat about the Celtics lack of effort in Game 6. He discusses how Bradley has enhanced Rondo's play, the C's lack of depth dues to injury, and what the Celtics need to do to win Game 7.
Sean talked with the coach about the big Game 5 comeback, and about the team's different configurations.
Paul talks with Sean & Max about Avery Bradley's health, and about the Celtics' history with closeout games.
NESN Red Sox analyst Jerry Remy joined the guys to discuss why the Sox have been playing better since their players only meeting. He touches on how fun its been to watch their makeshift lineup play, Bobby Valentine's shuffling his roster due to injuries, and Adrian Gonzalez willingness to play the outfield to help the team.
Bobby Valentine & Joe Castiglione on a rare no-move day today in Baltimore to preview Sox/irds
Red Sox Manager Bobby Valentine joined D&C to discuss Kevin Youkilis' return from the DL. He also discusses juggling his lineup with all the injuries, Adrian Gonzalez volunteering to play the outfield, team leadership, and how the players only meeting influenced the Sox turnaround.
Bruins Defensman Andrew Ference wraps up the Bruins Game 7 loss. He touches on just how the Capitals beat them, what his thought were on Ovechkin's performance, and how Tim Thomas' decision not to attend the White House visit affected the team.
NESN's Andy Brickley joined Dennis and Callahan to discuss the NHL playoffs and preview game 7 of the Bruins and Captials.
We're joined by NESN's own Jack Edwards after the Bruins knocked off the Caps in dramatic fashion to force a game 7 showdown this Wednesday at the Garden. Jack says: Bet on the Bear!
Celtics radio analyst Cedric Maxwell joined D&C to chat about the Celtics lack of effort in Game 6. He discusses how Bradley has enhanced Rondo's play, the C's lack of depth dues to injury, and what the Celtics need to do to win Game 7.
NESN Red Sox analyst Jerry Remy joined the guys to discuss why the Sox have been playing better since their players only meeting. He touches on how fun its been to watch their makeshift lineup play, Bobby Valentine's shuffling his roster due to injuries, and Adrian Gonzalez willingness to play the outfield to help the team.
D&C discuss Lisa Salters interview/lovefest with Allen Iverson in the middle of the 2nd quater of Game 6. The boys talk about the timing and length of the interview, how broke Iverson is, and the impressive run the Celtics had during the interview.
Buster Olney joins Mut and Lou to discuss the latest on the Youkilis trade front, Bob McClure, what Cole Hamels will get in free agency, and if Hal Steinbrenner is really trying to sell the Yankees.
Mut and Lou try to figure out why Daniel Bard is no longer throwing in the high 90's.
Tim Legler joins Mut and Merloni to talk about the Celtics loss to the Sixers and what he expects will happen in Game 7.
As the news comes down that Gonzalez is playing in the outfield, we debate how smart a move this is, and what, if any, alternatives did the Red Sox have?
Former NBA player/current analyst for TNT Steve Kerr chatted with Glenn and Michael and gave his thoughts on the Celts/Sixers, Heat/Pacers and Thunder/Spurs series'.
Even with the Celtics make a nice run in the Eastern Conference NBA playoffs, watching Oklahoma City and San Antonio play has made it abundantly clear that one of those teams will likely win the whole thing. We discuss.
Kirk wrote a column about David Ortiz that Mikey didn't completely agree with and a debate ensues.
Ryder and Kirk talk about what the Red Sox might do when their injured position players start making their return to the lineup and what that could mean for the struggling Kevin Youkilis.
Ryder and Kirk Minihane are talking about Josh Becketts impressive outing against the Seattle Mariners. They also talk about the Celtics-76ers series and how much energy the Celtics will have in game 3.
MOTWU tickles Michael, Ortiz feels the heat, and the Celts get their props.
The goon croons for a lost BeeGee, and Metallica on the accordion never sounded better.
Rhode Islanders vs Schilling... and they ain't happy.
Celtics head coach Doc Rivers called into D&C this morning to discuss his team's dominating second half performance in Game 5. He touches on how the C's clicked in the second half, the character of his team, why Rondo is so special, and the keys to Brandon Bass' big night.
More from this showFormer NBA player/current analyst for TNT Steve Kerr chatted with Glenn and Michael and gave his thoughts on the Celts/Sixers, Heat/Pacers and Thunder/Spurs series'.
More from this showCeltics TV play-by-play voice Mike Gorman joined John & Gerry to discuss the personality of this Celtics team. He also talks about if the Celtics are taking this season as their last shot at a championship, what was the key moment that turned the season around, and if KG will return to Boston next season.
More from this showMut and Lou discuss David Ortiz's comments after last night's game about not getting enough respect from the front office and media.
More from this showKirk talks with John Mitchell, who wrote Wednesday that Kevin Garnett could face backlash from racist fans in Boston should the Celtics lose the series to the 76ers.
More from this show