FOXBORO -- Whether he gets a chance to play out his entire career in a Patriots uniform or ends up finishing with another franchise, there will be a day when Tom Brady is no longer the Patriots’ quarterback. And with Brady turning 35 earlier this month, that day will come sooner rather than later.
The Packers had Aaron Rodgers ready to go when Brett Favre left. The 49ers had Steve Young backing up Joe Montana. And while no one is suggesting that Brian Hoyer or Ryan Mallett have that same pedigree, the Patriots have to start planning for life after Brady.
With Hoyer and Mallett currently working as the backup and third-string quarterbacks respectively, the Patriots appear to be better off than most teams when it comes to quarterback depth. But what about the post-Brady era? Does the organization view either one as a possible successor to the current quarterback? And what are some of their pluses and minuses?
If you’re looking for Brady Lite, you could do a lot worse than Hoyer. The 26-year-old undrafted free agent out of Michigan State has been in the New England system for three years, and while he’s no Brady, when he’s gotten the chance to run the show, he’s shown himself to be a fairly steady and consistent presence under center. In this year’s training camp, he’s consistently made the proper reads, not tried to bite off too much and delivered the ball in a good spot for his receivers.
Granted, it’s tough to evaluate him on his regular-season resume: In three years, he’s played in 13 games and gone 27-for-43 for 286 yards with one touchdown and one interception. However, a clearer picture of Hoyer emerges when you look at his preseason numbers: In 11 contests, he’s gone 94-for-158 (a 59 percent completion rate) with 1,166 yards, six touchdowns and one interception. (That includes an 8-for-15 effort with 45 yards passing and one touchdown last Thursday against the Saints. It was a night that included the finest offensive sequence of the evening for the Patriots, a 14-play, 97-yard drive that ended with the only touchdown of the game.)
Those preseason numbers must be taken with a grain of salt, obviously, but if you’re using 60 percent as an optimal completion rate, Hoyer’s numbers are favorable. He’s had three games where he’s had more than 170 yards passing (in all of those games, he’s completed 15 or more passes). Another stat that jumps out is one interception on 158 pass attempts in the preseason -- or two in 201 pass attempts, when you combine his preseason and regular-season work -- which shows excellent decision-making skills.
In fact, Hoyer’s preseason numbers compare very favorably to a former Brady backup who went on to land a fat new contract later in his career. From 2005 through 2008, Matt Cassel played in 16 preseason games over the course of his four years in New England, and finished 119-for-211 for 56 percent. He threw for 1,331 yards, with four touchdowns and five interceptions.
Given Hoyer’s track record and history, if he was pressed into service as a starter this year in New England, it wouldn’t be surprising if -- after a game or two to find his footing -- he would react much like Cassel did in 2008, when he led New England to an 11-5 mark. (In other words, he’s no Curtis Painter.)
There’s some uncertainty around Hoyer’s future in Foxboro -- after playing out his first deal, he signed a one-year, $1.927 million deal in the offseason, and so the team must make up its mind relatively quickly if it wants to keep him long term.
As for Mallett, he remains a bit of an enigma. The 24-year-old out of Arkansas, who is entering his second season in the league, has ridiculous arm strength -- in training camp, he has made some deep throws that Brady would struggle with. While Hoyer frequently settles for the safer play, Mallett doesn’t seem to fear opening it up. But at the same time, he’s shown inconsistency when it comes to short and intermediate routes. In some ways, he compares with Jay Cutler: great arm strength, but occasionally questionable decision-making.
Mallett fundamentally took a redshirt season last year, but in four preseason games (three last year and one this year), he has a stat line of 32-for-63 for 282 yards with no touchdowns and a pair of interceptions. In the preseason opener last week against the Saints, it was an uneven performance, as he made some good throws, but he also appeared to be thinking and reacting as opposed to making snap decisions much of the night.
Despite the contrast, while Hoyer may be the more palatable quarterback for the Patriots in the long run, Mallett is likely a better trade chip. He’s younger and he’s under contract for three more years as opposed to Hoyer’s one. And when it comes to other teams, the tacit endorsement of the Patriots (who took him in the third round in 2011) can go a long way in a quarterback-starved league.
Ultimately, all of this depends on Brady’s own timeline. If the quarterback decides to play another five years until he’s 40 (as he has said on several occasions), Brady’s heir is neither Mallett or Hoyer, but some collegian (or even a high schooler). But until Brady’s time in New England is done, the two will sit and wait for their opportunity.
CHRISTOPHER PRICE
In the latest edition of the "It Is What It Is" podcast, Chris Price and CSNNE's Mike Giardi take a look at the Patriots offseason on both sides of the ball, try and get a handle on which new guys will make an impact first, and whether or not the Patriots have altered their style when it comes to drafting and developing wide receivers.
Mike Florio joined the program to discuss the Jets decision to release Tim Tebow, he said the situation is as disaster all around for the Jets and that the problems begins with owner Woody Johnson. Mike also said that he was disappointed with the Pats moving back in the first round.
One of the hardest working men in the biz, Mike Petraglia aka "Trags", sits down with Butch Stearns live in Foxborough to help break down all the latest Pats moves. He discusses his reaction to the trade in Round 1 and the guys those picks produced. Also, the boys talk about the decent trade the Pats made in acquiring LeGarrette Blount from Tampa Bay for Jeff Demps and a 7th rounder.
We check in with Danny Ainge for our first talk to him since the Celtics season ended last weekend. We talk about the future of the team, KG, Pierce, Doc Rivers and more, as Danny directly answers the rumors being floated by ESPN's Stephen A. Smith.
Jackie Mac joins the show to discuss the trade rumors swirling around Paul Pierce, KG, Doc Rivers and the Celtics. She also discusses the future of the Celtics head coach.
Stephen A. joined the program to discuss the trade rumors he has reported regarding a possible trade including Doc Rivers and the Clippers. Stephen A. also told the guys that he has heard that Danny and Doc may be tiring of working together.
Joe Castiglione talked with John Lackey after he picked up the W against the Twins. Lackey threw seven innings, and retired the 1st twelve batters of the game.
Dave O'Brien talked to John Farrell before the end of the Twins series. The Sox skipper said that Big Papi's success is no surprise given his work ethic.
John Farrell postgame press conference
Elliotte Friedman joined the show to discuss the Bruins domination of the series thus far. He said that while nothing is certain he cannot see a way in which the Rangers come back and win the series.
Brickley joins the show and discusses what the Bruins should do with their young defensemen once the veterans return from injury, the play of Rask, and Torterella's coaching style.
Shawn joined the show to discuss the teams great performance in game two against the Rangers. Shawn said that he wouldn't mind playing for John Tortorella because he seems like a funny guy.
Elliotte Friedman joined the show to discuss the Bruins domination of the series thus far. He said that while nothing is certain he cannot see a way in which the Rangers come back and win the series.
Steve joined the show to discuss the Rangers and their coach John Tortorella. Steve said that the Bruins have been the far better team thus far in the series.
Kirk and Gerry talked about game three tonight at Madison Square Garden between the Bruins and Rangers. Gerry and Kirk are not very confident in the ability of the Rangers to make this a series.
Brickley joins the show and discusses what the Bruins should do with their young defensemen once the veterans return from injury, the play of Rask, and Torterella's coaching style.
LB joins the show in studio to discuss the Bruins taking a 2-0 series lead against the Rangers and what Claude should do when Seidenberg, Redden, and Ference are ready to play.
Mut and Merloni get into a Red Sox discussion after a successful weekend in Minnesota. They discuss Pedroia, Lackey, and the future of Ellsbury with the Red Sox.
What's better than a whole hour with NESN's Jack Edwards? Not much. We talk all hockey, all the time with Jack live from his study, with a "Loving Cup", whatever that is.
We talk hockey as the Bruins have had little problem taking a 2-0 series lead against the much talk about NY Rangers. Will this continue in games 3 and 4 at MSG? We discuss.
We tackle four topics we haven't yet touched upon today. Gronk!, Proms with celebs and athletes and much more.
Today on the Daily Planet the Bruins have a 2-0 lead over the New york Rangers, the Red Sox are back on the winning sde of things, and the noteable birthdays of the day.
The Bruins have almost finished raking the Leafs, the Red Sox struggle from the mound, Miami Heat fans show their level of class.
Daily Planet Wednesday May 8th
....uhhhh.....a bunch of bombs over there....
Sounds like a prostate exam to me!
Damn New Yorkers!
Linda explains how the shootout transpired in Watertown during the early morning hours. She saw the first suspect mortally wounded and police beginning the manhunt for the second suspect.
More from this showWe check in with Danny Ainge for our first talk to him since the Celtics season ended last weekend. We talk about the future of the team, KG, Pierce, Doc Rivers and more, as Danny directly answers the rumors being floated by ESPN's Stephen A. Smith.
More from this showBy and large, the focus of development in the minor leagues is on players. Still, there is a developmental path for coaches and managers in the farm system, as is evident from the fact that the previous two managers of the Red Sox' Triple-A affiliate in Pawtucket -- Torey Lovullo (2010) and Arnie Beyeler (2011-12) are now both on the Red Sox' big league coaching staff. They share their insights about the differences between player and coaching expectations in Triple-A vs. the majors, while discussing professional development from the perspective of former minor league managers who aspire to similar positions in the big leagues.
More from this showJohn, Gerry and Kirk give their things that they would never do, listeners joined on the WEEI yakoff app with their thoughts.
More from this showJeff Bauman, a victim of the Boston Marathon bombing, joined the show to give the guys an update of his condition and a first-hand account of that terrible day. Jeff told the guys how he wrote the description of the bomber as soon as he could. Mr. Bauman added that he is aided every day with the knowledge that he is alive and the terrorist that detonated the bomb is dead.
More from this show