"Just because we're in the fact-checking era …" -- Bobby Valentine to Bob Costas Tuesday night.
Exactly.
You knew it was coming. There were murmurs that Valentine had been so quiet since his dismissal as manager from the Red Sox because a confidentiality agreement had been penned somewhere along the way. Well, if that is truly the case, wake up the lawyers or start reviewing the fine print. The airing of grievances this time didn't take place in Valentine's restaurant, as was the case when he got canned from the Mets job in 2002. It was in an NBC Sports studio across from an extremely sympathetic Costas.
That's fine. It's understandable that Valentine would want to start bearing his soul. But, true to form, the execution was botched once again.
For the former Red Sox manager, this was about setting the record straight. This version of the tale, however, was filled with wrong terms. And those who take Valentine's accounts as gospel are the equivalent of the Michael Scott character in "The Office" who drove his car into a lake after misinterpreting the directions given by his GPS.
Let's start with the incident that followed Valentine's "fact-checking" comment to Costas, a moment involving Will Middlebrooks.
Valentine to Costas: “I don’t think the thing with Will ever happened. He told me he didn’t remember it, and I didn’t remember it.”
That's funny, because this is what he told a gathering of media after volunteering the story of how a member of the Red Sox upper management had talked to him after a player had complained about Valentine's treatment of the rookie after in inning in Chicago:
"[Middlebrooks] came into the dugout, he made a couple of errors and I said, 'Nice inning, kid.' I had thought I had established a relationship with him where I could say something like that and he would try to smile or relax a little. Maybe he grimaced, I don't know, but somebody overheard it and decided that it was a very dreadful thing for a manager to say to a young player, and decided to repeat it a few times, this dreadful thing. And that person didn't go to the locker room when I went with Will after the game to explain to him when I made three errors in a game and I was 21 years old and the fans went and booed me off the field and how I got through it and other people get through it, it's a great learning experience. I don't think that Will has been mortally wounded by that two-and-a-half month ago comment."
And while Middlebrooks took to Twitter Tuesday night to try and defuse the situation by also suggesting it didn't happen, the reality was that word had been passed throughout the clubhouse in the days following the June 17 incident that such an exchange had taken place.
Within that same line of questioning by Costas was also the topic of Valentine being confronted by players after ridiculing Aviles during a pop-up drill in spring training.
Valentine to Costas: “The thing with Aviles, it was absolutely mind-boggling. … We were going to have a discussion about it while we were running a drill. I just said guys, on this matter, this is not a democracy. We’re doing it the way you do it in baseball. I did it in a loud voice. Guys came into my office and said, ‘Please, don’t yell at Mike like that.’ … I’m still incredulous.
“Was I surprised that guys came in in that situation? Yes. I think … that’s unique to that group of guys. I don’t think it’s indiginous to all of baseball. At least I pray it’s not. It’s not functional with the tail wagging the dog, and taking a vote every time you have to decide how to do things. A leader needs to lead. He leads by forming the pack, patting down the pack and having other people follow. You can’t have the guy at the back of the line coming up and deciding which direction you’re going to go in.”
Well, no matter how Valentine viewed the incident, here's the problem -- the players felt like it was a big deal, with multiple voices in the Red Sox clubhouse even saying during the final series of the season that the Aviles incident was the one that set much of the disharmony in motion. So instead of understanding the result of his actions, for better or worse, Valentine's time and effort since has been only to defend those actions.
The same can be said regarding his recounting of the Kevin Youkilis saga, which he told Costas was precipitated by a "benign" comment. Again, when questioning a player's emotional state leads to such clubhouse furor, it doesn't matter what the purveyor of the words might think.
Then there was Valentine's take on his comment to The Big Show regarding some of his coaches potentially undermining him.
Valentine to Costas: "I think I said 'maybe.'
Actually, when Glenn Ordway asked the question whether or not Valentine felt he had been undermined by his coaches, the then-manager's answer was, "Yes." A small thing, but it magnifies the overall trend here of not quite squeezing in all the truth. It is the equivalent of Valentine telling fascinating baseball stories during spring training only to have Baseball-Reference.com documentation paint a slightly less interesting picture.
And then there was what President Obama might have classified as the biggest whopper of them all, the David Ortiz salvo.
Valentine to Costas: “David Ortiz came back after spending about six weeks on the disabled list and we thought it was only going to be a week. He got two hits the first two times up, drove in a couple runs; we were off to the races. Then he realized that this trade meant that we’re not going to run this race and we’re not even going to finish the race properly and he decided not to play anymore. I think at that time it was all downhill from there.”
Here's the reality, one which Valentine, of all people should have remembered: When Ortiz came back from his injury for that August 24 game, he was far from healed. In fact, some put him at barely 75 percent, which was evident when watching the designated hitter run the bases during those two hits Valentine referenced. Ortiz was getting frustrated with not being able to contribute to what was a 60-66 team at the time, and demanded to play. Two weeks later, when the Red Sox were 63-76, the DH was still limping. But rather than conceding that his season was over, he sought a form of treatment -- a plasma-rich platelet injection -- in late-August with the hope that he could return, saving the more traumatic shockwave therapy (which would have been a season-ender) until after the conclusion of the year.
What made Valentine's comments even more tough to stomach was, by all accounts, Ortiz was one player who routinely stood up for Valentine in the midst of teammates' criticism. It was a tact that didn't go unnoticed by Valentine until, evidently, he sat across from Costas.
There were other head-scratchers in the interview, such as a story about leaving three envelopes in the manager's office for the new manager, explaining who to blame if things go wrong. (According to those who have been through the office, those envelopes haven't yet been uncovered.)
Valentine would often say he understood that people were going to blame him for everything, pretending to embrace such a scenario for the sake of the team. But it became too much about fortifying his armor for such perceived attacks, a reality that clearly led to the former manager's revisionist recollections of his time in Boston.
Here is the true fact: This interview, and these explanations, were inevitable. Wrong, but inevitable, nonetheless.
ROB BRADFORD
Pete joined the show to discuss Tebow's signing with the Patriots. He said that Tim Tebow cant play and that he has trouble learning NFL playbooks.
On this episode of the It Is What It Is Cast, Chris Price talks with the Boston Herald's Jeff P Howe about the Patriots offseason, Rob Gronkowski's back surgery, Danny Amendola replacing Wes Welker, and how this seasons team will stack up against last seasons.
In the latest edition of the It Is What It Is Cast, Chris Price talks with Will Carroll. Injury expert and lead writer for Sports Medicine, Bleacher Report. They talk about the injury to Rob Gronkowski and what his back surgery could mean for his season.
Jeff joined the show to discuss the rumors of Doc heading to the Clippers. Jeff said that he will not discuss his future but that his brother would be a great candidate anywhere.
Stephen A. joined the show to discuss the status of trade negotiations between the Clippers and the Celtics. Stephen said that it is a 50-50 proposition that Doc ends up in Los Angeles.
Grande and Max take more calls on the Celtics and discuss what lies ahead for Doc Rivers with Steve Bulpett.
John Farrell postgame press conference
Dave O'Brien talked to John Farrell before the last game of the Baltimore series. The skipper said that the Sox have played tough through this stretch of long games.
Jonny Gomes talked to Joe Castiglione & Dave O'Brien after the third game of the Baltimore series. The Sox slugger hit a homer and scored two runs in the win.
Pierre McGuire joins Mut and Merloni after a Bruins win and discusses the play of Rask and the defense, the Hossa injury, and Jagr.
Tony Amonte calls out Marian Hossa for missing Game 3 and recaps the Bruins win.
Barry joined the show to discuss the Bruins 2-0 win over the Blackhawks in game three. Barry continues to be impressed by the play of Bergeron.
Barry joined the show to discuss the Bruins 2-0 win over the Blackhawks in game three. Barry continues to be impressed by the play of Bergeron.
Jeff joined the show to discuss the rumors of Doc heading to the Clippers. Jeff said that he will not discuss his future but that his brother would be a great candidate anywhere.
The guys opened the show discussing the Bruins' dominating Game 3 win over the Blackhawks. Gerry thinks the series is over.
Pierre McGuire joins Mut and Merloni after a Bruins win and discusses the play of Rask and the defense, the Hossa injury, and Jagr.
Tony Amonte calls out Marian Hossa for missing Game 3 and recaps the Bruins win.
Andy Brickley joins Mut and Merloni in studio to take phone calls from the listeners and to preview Game 3 of the Stanley Cup.
We talk all Bruins, all the time with the man himself, Jack Edwards from NESN gets us ready for game three and beyond.
Four guys, four topics we haven't yet touched upon today. TO visits Ocho, Bob Costas has enough smarm for us all, stupid beauty pageant contestants and more.
We talk about the Bruins big showdown with the Blackhawks tonight at the Garden with the lovely and knowledgeable Kathryn Tappen of the NHL Network.
Mikey gets a surprise call from Bernie Carbo, they talk about old time baseball and Bernie's new book.
Mikey talks with Tom and Luke about their new movie, Plimpton! and finds out what it was like to try to encapsulate everything Plimpton accomplished during his life.
Today on the Daily Planet, the Red Sox and Yankees face off in the Bronx, Claude Julien doesn't want players wasting energy, and Dwight Howard and free agency.
You ask, we answer. Today featuring NESN's Jack Edwards.
The new way we end the show. You ask, we answer.
You ask, we answer... anything!
The guys opened the show discussing ESPN's NBA coverage and how Bill Simmons has lost his edge in recent years. Gerry praised Bill for anti-ESPN tweets following the coverage of Game 4.
More from this showStephen A. joined the show to discuss the status of trade negotiations between the Clippers and the Celtics. Stephen said that it is a 50-50 proposition that Doc ends up in Los Angeles.
More from this showShawn joined the show to discuss the Bruins' OT win in Chicago. Shawn said that there was a heated discussion during the first intermission Saturday night in Chicago after the team's poor first period.
More from this showThe guys opened the show discussing the rumors regarding Doc Rivers being part of a deal between the Celtics and the Clippers.
More from this showBoth Xander Bogaerts and Anthony Ranaudo punctuated their strong 2013 seasons with head-turning events on June 13. On that day, Bogaerts, the Red Sox' top prospect, was promoted from Double-A Portland Pawtucket, with the 20-year-old becoming one of the youngest position players in the affiliate's history. On that same day, right-hander Anthony Ranaudo punched out 13 batters for Double-A Portland, the most strikeouts by a Red Sox minor leaguer since Jon Lester in 2005. They joined Minor Details to discuss both those accomplishments and their seasons to date.
More from this show