A couple of weeks ago in a midseason Red Sox report card I posed this question:
Taking everything into account -- age, durability, established performance level, postseason history, AL vs. NL, current contract status -- is there a pitcher in baseball you would absolutely trade Jon Lester for?
Think about it. Lester is just entering his prime at 26 years old, has no injury history save for the bout with cancer (credit to how good Lester's been that we don't even think about that anymore), and is already one of the top 10 pitchers in the league, putting up Cy Young kind of numbers while pitching in the AL East. Throw in that he's signed for the next four years at a total of $38 million and you've got someone really close to untradeable status.
Before we run down the list of guys that have a case, I made the decision to eliminate any pitchers over 32 years old (goodbye to Roy Halladay, Chris Carpenter, Tim Hudson, Roy Oswalt and Tatum O'Neal) or making over $100 million (C.C. Sabathia, Johan Santana). Figured six years age difference or $10-15 million more a year in salary was a fair cutoff point.
So here we go. We've got the best of the under-32 and under $100 million crowd. Is there someone out there worth moving Lester for?
(And yes, I know that the Red Sox aren't going to trade Jon Lester. This is just one of those baseball arguments, that's all. Something to discuss between stories about Deanna Favre renewing her gym membership in Minnesota and the future of Chad Qualls. Oh, and 2010 stats are through 7/28)
--
Philip Hughes
Having a nice season (12-3, 4.04 ERA), is two and a half years younger than Lester and isn't eligible for free agency until 2014, but he hasn't shown enough to be considered in the class of a Lester. Hasn't had a full season as a starter yet, forget a kind of season that could match up to Lester in 2008 or 2009. And he's slowing down already, with an ERA over 5.00 in both June and July. He could become a legit No. 1 for the Yankees in the next couple of years, but he's not there yet.
The Verdict (or would you trade Lester for him): Not even close.
--
Jered Weaver
Weaver was every bit the pitcher John Lackey was over the last half-decade, at least the co-ace of the Angels staff. Now with Lackey gone he's stepped up and turned into a no-doubt No. 1. He leads the AL with 155 K's and his WHIP and ERA are also both in the top six. His career record and ERA match up nicely with Lester's. So why is this an easy "no"? Couple of reasons: One, his home/road splits. His ERA at home in 3.04 in 63 career starts, 4.21 in 69 career road starts. And this is serious small sample size, but his career ERA at Fenway is 7.06 and 6.08 at the new Yankee Stadium (and 5.63 at the old Yankee Stadium). I wonder if he'd be the same pitcher outside of Angel Stadium and the cozy AL West. Also he's not locked into a long-term deal and his agent is Scott Boras.
The Verdict: Nope.
(Sorry, got one eye on the TV and I'm watching the David Tyree stuff. Looks like he's retiring -- nice way to say no one wants him -- and is going to sign a one-day deal with the Giants. Is this pushing the one-day rule? I know Tyree made his mark, but the guy had like 12 catches in his career. What's the cutoff? Just have to play a key role in a title? Tyree could set a dangerous precedent. Could Kevin Millar have done it? Or how about J.R. Redmond?)
--
Already crashing back to Ubaldo Jimenzville (an ERA of 4.41 in June and 7.59 in July). He has to be on the list because he's 15-2 with a 2.75 ERA, but this screams "fluke season." Tough to imagine that his ERA will be south of 3.00 at the end of the season.
The Verdict: No.
Here's a question, though. Is "The Karate Kid" the only teen movie in history where the female lead outweighs her love interest?
--
Mat Latos
Still trying to figure out how he wasn't on the NL All-Star Team. Latos leads the NL in WHIP (0.99) and has struck out nearly a batter an inning (106 in 112.2 IP). He's a couple of years younger than Lester and under club control for the next six years, but like Hughes the body of work just isn't enough to consider giving up a pitcher like Lester.
The Verdict: No.
--
Matt Cain
Here's what you have to love about Cain -- he figured it out. After the 2008 season Cain had three full seasons as a starter under the ol' belt. His walk rate per nine innings in those seasons was 4.1, 3.6 and 3.8. But he's matured, you know that? A 3.0 per nine rate in 2009 and 3.1 in 2010. Big drops in WHIP and ERA has followed as well. At the same time, however, his K rate has dropped (8.4 per nine in 2006, 6.7 this season) while Lester's has jumped (10.0 in 2009 and 9.5 this season). Lester has a better contract (Cain is due $22.5 million over the next two years, which is about a million less than Lester will make over the next three years) and has proven he can get it done in the AL East. Cain works in a pitcher's park, no DH, and in a division that has no Yankees or Rays.
The Verdict: It's a pretty easy pass.
--
Yovani Gallardo
I like him, but A) he walks way too many guys (nearly four per nine innings in his career, he walked 30 more batters than Lester in 18 fewer innings pitched last season) and B) has had some serious knee issues.
The Verdict: I don't know, I can't imagine the Red Sox trading Jon Lester for a guy that ranks 29th in the NL in WHIP. It's a no.
--
Cliff Lee
Sneaks in here because he's under 32 years old (turns 32 August 30) and isn't a member of the $100 million club. That's going to change, clearly. Lee has to be looking at a nine-figure contract from someone, right?
This is the first pitcher on the list that I would absolutely swap straight up for Lester for the rest of the season, but that's not really what we are asking here. Gotta take it all in (that's the only time in this column that I'll borrow a line from the transcript of the Rick Pitino extortion trial). Cliff Lee is a better pitcher than Jon Lester. I'll buy that. But is the difference between the two worth giving up six years in age and what will probably be close to $50 million dollars in salary over the next four years? Not a chance.
The Verdict: No.
--
One of the legitimate aces in the AL, but his contract ($73 million over the next four years) and career road numbers (4.21 ERA, 1,34 WHIP) make this a no-go.
This is why win-loss records mean almost nothing. Verlander and Lester are about a wash this year in win-loss, Verlander 12-6, Lester 11-5. But look at the other stats:
WHIP: Lester 1.09, Verlander, 1.20
ERA: Lester, 2.92, Verlander, 3.74
Hits per nine: Lester, 6.6, Verlander, 7.7
Ks per nine: Lester, 9.5, Verlander 8.5
K/BB: Lester, 2.98, Verlander, 2.65
Throw this into the "small sample that could mean something or nothing" category. In eight career postseason appearances Lester has a 2.57 ERA. In four career postseason appearances Verlander has a 5.82 ERA.
The Verdict: The difference in salary is huge, but the truth is that Lester is a better pitcher and that's reason No. 1 why this is a no.
--
The point is that we don't know. He could be Nolan Ryan or Kerry Wood or Roger Clemens or David Clyde. Remember how good Jaret Wright was as a rookie?
Strasburg could pitch 22 years in the majors and this might be the only time he ever spends on the DL. Or he could be Mark Prior, spending half his prime making rehab starts and the other half in Dr. Andrews waiting room. The point is we don't know.
I hope he's great. He sure looks the part so far. He's the best young pitcher I've seen since Doc Gooden. Doc finished his career with 194 wins and a 3.51 ERA, numbers that 99.99 percent of pitchers would take for a career but way short of the massive expectations for Gooden. I'm serious, 330 wins and a 2.50 ERA seemed possible in 1985. If you had told me on Opening Day 1986 that Jamie Moyer could finish his career with 100 more wins than Dwight Gooden I would not have known what language you were speaking.
Strasburg isn't Gooden, obviously. But there is so much unknown with him that the Red Sox couldn't pull the trigger on a deal. By the way, the Nationals wouldn't make the deal, either. The guy is the Nationals. There is nobody -- Albert Pujols, Hanley Ramirez, Joe Mauer -- the Nationals would even consider. And that's the right move for a team that needs a face. The Red Sox don't care about faces, they sell tickets OK.
The Verdict: On ESPN killing the LeBron in Vegas story? Typically gutless. Nothing those strippers did to LeBron in the story I read was as degrading as what Jim Gray did on "The Decision" or Robin Roberts' tongue bath the next day on "Good Morning America." Oh, you mean Strasburg for Lester? That's a no.
--
Clayton Kershaw
The pros: 22 years old, making about 400K this season and is under club control for the next half decade, has over a K an inning average for his career, ERA and WHIP have gone down in each season, doesn't give up homers (0.5 per game in his career, second-fewest in NL in 2009 and sixth this season), first guy since Fritz Von Erich to pull off "The Claw" as a nickname.
The cons: Stop if you've read this already -- NL West pitcher with dramatic home/road splits (career 2.62 ERA and 1.20 WHIP at Dodgers Stadium, 4.00 ERA and 1.42 WHIP on the road) and control problems (career 4.4 walks per nine innings). Kershaw has terrific stuff, is young and strikes out enough guys that he probably wouldn't be a victim of the "NL to AL" curse.
The Verdict: Again, not worth the risk when you've got a sure thing in Lester.
--
Here's what I wrote a few weeks ago in my midseason Red Sox report card …
"Johnson is interesting. He and Lester are basically the same age (Lester is three and half weeks older) and have similar career lines. Lester has a career record of 53-19, Johnson 43-19. Lester has a career 8.1/3.3 K/BB ratio, Johnson's is 8.2/3.0. WHIP? Lester's is 1.29, Johnson 1.23. But push to shove I'm still going with the guy I know can pitch in the AL East."
That's the thing -- Lester is already one of the, what, six or seven best pitchers in baseball on numbers alone, forgetting where he pitches and in what division. Factor that in and it's tough to make the case that a guy with basically the same numbers in the NL East (though admittedly having a unreal 2010) is going to come to Boston and pitch better. Not a big track record of that happening.
The Verdict: No.
--
Adam Wainwright
The best pitcher in baseball since the start of the 2009 season -- 33-14 with a 2.47 ERA. Right now the Cy Young is Johnson's to lose, but Wainwright is going to finish in the top three for the second straight season. I bet the Cardinals would turn down a Lester offer, and it would be tough to blame them. But I think I'd keep Lester if the Cards called. Wainwright is 29 years old, three years older than Lester. If the two were the same age I'd trade Lester for Wainwright. If Wainwright was three years older than Lester but had put up these same numbers with the Yankees or Rays I'd probably make the deal. But the age difference (three years is 100 starts, 600 innings, not insignificant) and the NL-AL stuff would be deal-breakers for me.
The Verdict: A very close no.
-
Felix Hernandez
Comes down to this and only this: Felix Hernandez is going to make $68 million over the next four years, Lester $38 million. I'm OK with the idea that Felix Hernandez is a better pitcher than Lester, but $7.5 million a year better?
The Verdict: Only if Seattle is willing to kick in the $30 million. Pretty good chance that would happen, right?
--
A better Phil Hughes for this debate. If Price can put up these kind of numbers for the next two years than you'd have to think he would be fair value for Lester. But it's wait and see for now. One other thing to remember about Price is that he'll be 25 in August. Seems he should be younger, probably because this is his first full season in the rotation. Not unlike Buchholz, it took some time for Price.
The Verdict: For now, no.
--
Having a "down" year, still 10-4 with a 3.12 ERA. One of the few guys that is just as good on the road (1.17 WHIP both home and road for career). When I kicked this column idea around I kind of figured Lincecum was the one lock, the one guy that I'd swap for Lester. Two Cy Youngs, great K rate (10.0 per nine), under team control until 2014, all that stuff. But you know what? I can't get past his size (5-11, 170) and delivery. I just think he's a serious injury waiting to happen. And Lester -- assuming the worst is over with his illlness -- has the size and delivery of a guy that will make 32-33 starts a year for the next decade.
The Verdict: No.
Let the homer bells ring. There isn't a pitcher in baseball -- again, taking all factors in account -- I would absolutely trade Jon Lester for.
--
Matt joined the program to discuss his first ever cornhole contest and to break down the Patriots offseason. He told the guys that he was upset that the Pats were unable to bring Wes Welker back to the team.
Tom Brady joined the program to discuss his upcoming charitable event supporting Best Buddies and his off-season. Tom said that he has learned not to worry about free agency decisions since he cant control any of them. Lastly he defended his over the top celebration at the Kentucky Derby.
In the latest edition of the "It Is What It Is" podcast, Chris Price and CSNNE's Mike Giardi take a look at the Patriots offseason on both sides of the ball, try and get a handle on which new guys will make an impact first, and whether or not the Patriots have altered their style when it comes to drafting and developing wide receivers.
Jackie MacMullan joins Mut and Merloni to discuss the latest rumors surrounding Celtics head coach Doc Rivers and whether he'll be back next season with the team.
We check in with Danny Ainge for our first talk to him since the Celtics season ended last weekend. We talk about the future of the team, KG, Pierce, Doc Rivers and more, as Danny directly answers the rumors being floated by ESPN's Stephen A. Smith.
Jackie Mac joins the show to discuss the trade rumors swirling around Paul Pierce, KG, Doc Rivers and the Celtics. She also discusses the future of the Celtics head coach.
Ben joined the program to discuss the return of Terry Francona and said that he always had a good relationship with the former manager. Ben added that he thinks Ellsbury is in a slump due in part to the amount of left handed pitchers the team has faced.
Salty spoke with Joe Castiglione & Dave O'Brien after he helped his team to a 6-2 victory over the Chicago White Sox tonight. The Red Sox return to Fenway after going 6-3 on the road trip.
We check in with Red Sox Manager John Farrell live from Chicago and get his take on a good week for the Sox, a tough series since then in Chicago, and other team related notes.
Andy Brickley joins the show to discuss what he expects to see from the Rangers tonight, why the Bruins match up well against them, and potentially closing out the series tonight
McGuire joins Mut and Merloni to discuss the Bruins game 3 win, the Rangers awful power play, and the Shawn Thornton Derek Dorsett altercation.
Shawn joined the program to discuss his big night at MSG. He told the guys that it is not Marchand's job to fight and that he needs to be on the ice and out of the penalty box.
Ben joined the program to discuss the return of Terry Francona and said that he always had a good relationship with the former manager. Ben added that he thinks Ellsbury is in a slump due in part to the amount of left handed pitchers the team has faced.
Matt joined the program to discuss his first ever cornhole contest and to break down the Patriots offseason. He told the guys that he was upset that the Pats were unable to bring Wes Welker back to the team.
Tom Brady joined the program to discuss his upcoming charitable event supporting Best Buddies and his off-season. Tom said that he has learned not to worry about free agency decisions since he cant control any of them. Lastly he defended his over the top celebration at the Kentucky Derby.
Andy Brickley joins the show to discuss what he expects to see from the Rangers tonight, why the Bruins match up well against them, and potentially closing out the series tonight.
One of the many Mut and Merloni callers, Meg in the Cape, chats with Mike and Lou about the Bruins and a whole bunch of other stuff in the span of about 2 min. Afterwards, Mut and Merloni hear some voice activated text messages from people listening in to Meg.
Jackie MacMullan joins Mut and Merloni to discuss the latest rumors surrounding Celtics head coach Doc Rivers and whether he'll be back next season with the team.
With the Bruins up 3-0 in the series, we talk to Jack Edwards and take your calls. We touch on all things B's-Rangers and also focus on the future of the Bruins three promising young defensemen.
We touch on four topics we haven't talked about today... topics today include: Brian Urlacher retires, NFL schedule expansion, Sergio Garcia and more...
We discuss Spain's Sergio Garcia and his ignorant, racist comments against Tiger Woods.
The Bruins look to take a 3-0 series lead, Jon Lester gets his first loss, Dwight Howard has options in free agency.
Today on the Daily Planet the Bruins have a 2-0 lead over the New york Rangers, the Red Sox are back on the winning sde of things, and the noteable birthdays of the day.
The Bruins have almost finished raking the Leafs, the Red Sox struggle from the mound, Miami Heat fans show their level of class.
The Jerks are joined by another, Jerk Minihane.
They're like a ray of morning sunshine on an otherwise gloomy day.
....uhhhh.....a bunch of bombs over there....
Linda explains how the shootout transpired in Watertown during the early morning hours. She saw the first suspect mortally wounded and police beginning the manhunt for the second suspect.
More from this showJeff Bauman, a victim of the Boston Marathon bombing, joined the show to give the guys an update of his condition and a first-hand account of that terrible day. Jeff told the guys how he wrote the description of the bomber as soon as he could. Mr. Bauman added that he is aided every day with the knowledge that he is alive and the terrorist that detonated the bomb is dead.
More from this showTerry Francona joins the Dennis and Callahan Show to discuss his first-place Indians team as well as his time in Boston. The former Boston manager also touches on his recent book co-authored by Dan Shaughnessy and Shaughnessy's recent dust-up with David Ortiz.
More from this showTom Brady joined the program to discuss his upcoming charitable event supporting Best Buddies and his off-season. Tom said that he has learned not to worry about free agency decisions since he cant control any of them. Lastly he defended his over the top celebration at the Kentucky Derby.
More from this showElliotte Friedman joined the show to discuss the Bruins domination of the series thus far. He said that while nothing is certain he cannot see a way in which the Rangers come back and win the series.
More from this show