FORT MYERS, Fla. – When the Red Sox talked to Jacoby Ellsbury about moving to left field for the 2010 season, the team wanted to make clear to the 26-year-old that it wasn’t a demotion.
The move reflected less on Ellsbury’s abilities in center, the team said, than on his prior performance (in both 2007 and 2008) playing left, and on new outfielder Mike Cameron’s comfort in center. The idea of shifting Ellsbury to left was not a knock on his defensive abilities.
But while Ellsbury and Boston might see it that way, the baseball industry as a whole would appear to have other ideas. That notion is encapsulated simply by this simple fact: no left fielder has been awarded a Gold Glove in the American League since Rickey Henderson snapped up the honor in 1981.
Though surprised by that fact, Ellsbury also understood the logic of it.
“I’m sure that since ’81, there have been some guys who can play a little left field,” said Ellsbury. “But typically, [Gold Gloves] go to your center fielder, and rightfully so. They’ve got to cover a lot more ground. I feel like they can be involved in a lot more plays.”
It may simply be a matter of neglect. As Ellsbury points out, there have been tremendous defensive left fielders. Carl Crawford is exceptional at the position, yet has never been given a Gold Glove award despite what most consider game-changing defense. He is not alone in having been overlooked at the position.
Center fielders are known for the highlight reel catches. Right fielders are viewed as game changers because of their arms. Left fielders, meanwhile, are typically typecast as the position players whose range and arms weren’t good enough for those more heralded positions. The absence of Rawlings-delivered hardware is a likely consequence.
“Centerfielders, you see them covering more ground, making more plays,” said Sox bench coach DeMarlo Hale, who had coached Boston’s outfielders for the prior four season. “The right fielders, maybe because they’re pretty good defenders and they have the types of arms that can change the game. You don’t run on Ichiro. You don’t run on certain guys with reputations. It affects how the third-base coach makes decisions.
“I think the reason why the Golds are in center and right is because of those things.”
Yet just because American League left fielders have been shut out of Gold Glove awards for nearly 30 years, it doesn’t mean that defenders can’t make an impact from that position. Both Hale and Ellsbury note that a player who can cover the ground of a center fielder while occupying left can impact significantly the amount of outfield lawn that gets covered.
As a left-handed defender, Ellsbury may be able to get to balls down the left field line with greater ease. At the same time, because he has what Hale describes as plus range (a notion that is endorsed by multiple scouts who watched him play the corners in parts of 2007 and 2008), he can provide greater coverage in the gap in left-center.
As such, ith Ellsbury in left, the Sox are likely to be able to shade both center fielder Cameron a bit more towards right-center to help J.D. Drew cover the massive expanse of real estate in right. That, the team hopes, will make for fewer balls dropping for hits. It is a subtle yet significant way in which a left fielder can impact a game defensively.
“With a left fielder who can cover a lot of ground, it can push everybody over, just like a good center fielder can push everybody over,” Ellsbury explained. “Cam can play a little more right, and push me and J.D. over a little bit more, let us play a little closer to the line. It compacts everything a little bit more.”
That is how Ellsbury is viewing his new station on the field. He does not take the positional shift as a slap in the face. Nor did he view the Sox’ request that he move out of center field to be an endorsement of some of the defensive metrics (like UZR and Plus/Minus) that described Ellsbury as having been below-average as a center fielder in 2009.
“I’m not losing any sleep over [those statistics],” Ellsbury chuckled. “I’m all in favor of stuff like that, but it’s so hard to be accurate.
“I haven’t really looked into it, but from what I understand, a deep fly ball into right field, if it’s sky high, that’s looked at as the same amount of range as a line drive that’s caught. How do you break that down?
“To me, it really can’t be accurately measured. What’s the difference with shifting? If you just take a diagram, if the strategy for the team is to play deep or play shallow, how does that factor? There are a lot of things that factor.
“What happens if it hits the Monster? It’s only X amount of feet, but you’re saying that another outfielder would have caught that ball. Well, I couldn’t because there’s a 50-foot Wall right there. How do you judge that?
“Maybe over time, they can take some of the kinks out of it. But for now, in my opinion, I don’t think it’s very accurate.”
Hale suggested that Ellsbury’s below-average defensive numbers might have reflected, in part, on the young center fielder’s deference to veteran teammates in the corner outfield positions. In that light, it is worth mentioning that Drew had two of the best three defensive seasons of his career as measured by UZR per 150 games in 2008 and 2009, with Ellsbury as the Sox’ primary center fielder.
In contrast to the portrayal of an outfielder with below-average numbers in 2009, Hale suggested that Ellsbury has the ability to excel at any of the three outfield positions. The Sox’ bench coach believes that Ellsbury has the necessary range and athleticism to claim the game’s highest defensive honor.
“Absolutely. Yes he does [have the ability to win a Gold Glove],” said Hale. “I think he’s capable of winning a Gold in either center or left. I really do.”
While the Sox believe that Ellsbury will eventually return to center, in 2010, any Gold Glove candidacy would have to be primarily on the strength of his work in left field. That obviously presents a formidable challenge for Ellsbury.
Yet the idea of trying to reverse almost 30 years of neglect for a position in the eyes of those who vote for the Gold Glove has plenty of appeal to the 26-year-old.
“I think I’m blessed with athletic ability – speed, the ability to read balls, that possibly one day [it could happen],” said Ellsbury. “I think it’d be pretty neat [to win one as a left fielder]. You’d obviously be in some elite company. Rickey Henderson, any time you throw his name around, it means you’re doing something pretty special on the field.”
ALEX SPEIER
The NFL Sunday gang wraps up the season predicting the score of Super Bowl 46...and they don't think it's going to be as close as most people do. Go Pats!
NFL Sunday rolls on with Dale, Fauria and Price talking about the emotional roller coaster the Pats and more specifically team owner Robert Kraft have been on this season. With the passing of his wife Myra, this goal to become champs has taken on a whole new meaning.
The NFL Sunday crew talks about the cocky and brash chatter coming from some of the Giants the last couple weeks. Dale is surprised that Tom Coughlin allowed most of it to go down and says Belichick would never let that fly. The guys also touch on the little mistake the Giants team website made yesterday in putting up the "Giants are Super Bowl Champions" homepage yesterday - that's a no-no!
JaJuan Johnson spoke with Grande & Max after the Celtics beat the Bulls today at the Garden.
Sean Grande & Cedric Maxwell sat down with ESPN's Doris Burke during halftime of Celtics/Bulls
Doc Rivers & Sean Grande preview Celtics-Bulls today at the Garden. Tune in to Celtics Today at 3:00p to hear the full interview
Dustin tells us you can't hustle a hustler, and other funny anecdotes.
The Sox GM joined Glenn and Michael to talk Scutaro, Punto, Oswalt, Luxury Tax and all things off-season.
Dustin Pedroia joined the Big Show for his weekly segment, and talked about losing Scutaro, gaining Cody Ross and Nick Punto, and then got a surprise from his best friend.
Brad Marchand joins the show and talks about if Tim Thomas is a distraction to the team and why the Bruins have been struggling as of late.
Andrew joins D&C to discuss how he feels about Tim Thomas' political views and how Patrice Bergeron has been the MVP for the team so far this season. Andrew also talks about how they have to regroup and make adjustments to get out this funk the team is currently in.
Brad Marchand joins the show to talk about President Obama calling him out on stage and Tim Thomas skipping the White House visit.
Jerry Sandusky addressed the media on Friday and offered comments on his current situation. Dino and Gerry react to those statements and do not think he should be allowed extra priveleges.
Dino, Gerry, and Mikey talk about their favorite moments from the Grammy Awards and react to the death of Whitney Houston.
Meter talks about the Celtics 88-87 OT loss to the Lakers last night, Kobe Bryant trying to recruit Rob Gronkowski to the Eagles, and Samantha DeFlaco who went to the Giants Super Bowl parade looking for Jets QB Mark Sanchez.
Brad Marchand joins the show and talks about if Tim Thomas is a distraction to the team and why the Bruins have been struggling as of late.
Jackie Mac makes her weekly appearance and talks about the Celtics loss to the Lakers, the team's future, and what will happen with Paul Pierce.
In an ugly game, the Celtics lost to the Lakers in OT. Have we seen the last of the current Lakers Celtics rivalry?
We play the soundbite from the NFL Network from Super Bowl 46 where Bill Belichick is telling his defense 'this is still a Cruz and Nicks game'. The Patriots of course were then burned by Mario Manningham on the Giants game-winning drive. We discuss whether it was the right decision or not.
Glenn and Michael debate what, if anything, Shaq is bringing to the table for TNT's NBA pre and postgame coverage.
We talk about Tim Thomas refusing to speak to reporters about his political ramblings on Facebook, and about whether or not this is a media driven controversy, or a genuine distraction for Thomas' Bruins teammates.
The discussion of the Patriots loss in the Super Bowl and just like any other loss, the coaching is called into question and whether a defensive coordinator on staff would have helped Bill Belichick and the Patriots.
Mikey has made no bones about his feelings on Pau Gasol, what will he do if the Celtics trade Rondo for Gasol? Also our buddy LB calls in to talk about the Patriots Super Bowl loss.
Mikey talks to some Patriots fans who are still looking at the loss and breaking down what went wrong but are also looking to the future for the franchise.
Losing the Super Bowl? Terrrrrrrrrrrrrrible.
This week's whine of the week winner. If you are our winner please send an email with which whine you left and all of your information to whineoftheweek@weei.com
Live from Hurricane's... not Cocaine's which is where Oil Can Boyd wanted to be broadcasting from. Plus the Cranky Yankee Bitch reaches her tipping point.
Our friend from Pittsburgh, Mark Madden, joins D&C to give his take on the Joe Paterno/Penn State scandal and says Jerry Sandusky may have been 'Pimping Out Young Boys to Rich Donors.'
More from this showGlenn and Michael debate what, if anything, Shaq is bringing to the table for TNT's NBA pre and postgame coverage.
More from this showD&C receive a second call from Joe in Nashville voicing his frustration over the Pats not bringing back Randy Moss during last offseason.
More from this showDustin joined Glenn and Michael on the Big Show, and they asked him if they could take a call. Dustin agreed, and the caller then went on to rip the crap out of him. What Dustin didn't know is that the caller was one of his best friends... Andre Ethier from the Dodgers.
More from this showMatt Perrault asks our listeners if they believe Bruin goalie Tim Thomas should take down his Facebook page. The media hasn't let down and Matt looks to dig deep into the situation. What do you think the Bruins should do?
More from this show